MIT Unveils New Robot Insect, Paving the Way Toward Rise of Robotic Pollinators
49 points
5 months ago
| 11 comments
| thedebrief.org
| HN
ChrisMarshallNY
5 months ago
[-]
Wasn’t there a sci-fi anthology series (maybe Black Mirror?) that had an episode, where a high-tech wizard used robot bees as weapons (particularly nasty ones)?
reply
senkora
5 months ago
[-]
reply
TechTechTech
5 months ago
[-]
Also see the video of Veritasium of 5 hours ago where his team visits this lab and the technology is explained in more depth.

https://youtu.be/H6q6pYZ9Fho

reply
josefritzishere
5 months ago
[-]
dystopian... is there something wrong with actual insects keeping their day jobs?
reply
doctoboggan
5 months ago
[-]
If you ever hear new robot + useful task always assume it's a cover story for weapons delivery. Why do you think so many new robots are advertised as great for "search and rescue after a disaster"? Its one config file away from search and kill in a war zone.
reply
bilbo0s
5 months ago
[-]
Insect-bots are the penultimate search and kill. Also the penultimate mass kill. The ultimate would have to be nanobots if we can ever get to reliable swarms of them.

But it’s not the weapons that interest me so much as what people come up with as countermeasures. It’ll be fascinating to watch the next few years.

reply
polishdude20
5 months ago
[-]
Imma invest in fly swatters
reply
getwiththeprog
5 months ago
[-]
Economics scares me more.
reply
sdwr
5 months ago
[-]
Insects don't want to work anymore! Lazy bastards keep complaining about pollution and climate change and pesticides
reply
mainecoder
5 months ago
[-]
This robotic pollinator can barely even fly for 45 sec, they cannot scale it sufficiently they can just say minidrone but to even think about using it as an actual pollinator and the economics making sense is at the present far far away.
reply
hulitu
5 months ago
[-]
Yes. They are being exterminated. The earthworms have almost dissapeared. The ants seem to still be able to survive though.
reply
tap-snap-or-nap
5 months ago
[-]
Insects are now free to do art...with subscription ai pushed by the big giant tech.
reply
nilamo
5 months ago
[-]
Maybe beekeeping is hard on Mars, so we need a new way to polinate the food supply?
reply
mystified5016
5 months ago
[-]
Extinction, generally.

I'd rather have combat insects we can turn into pollinators once the ecosystem collapses than have nothing at all.

reply
thesuitonym
5 months ago
[-]
I think I'd rather just have nothing at all.
reply
nomel
5 months ago
[-]
If you travel and see how people live in very large cities, especially in Asian countries, you'll find that interacting with any sort of nature is already optional for many people. These people won't notice. The indiscriminate pesticides will continue to flow, killing the natural bee/insect populations, with a slow transition to artificial pollination being an efficiency quirk of modern farming.
reply
Neonlicht
5 months ago
[-]
My mother used to work in social care for underprivileged city kids and she told me a story once where they took the kids to a farm. They were astonished that milk came from a cow.

I basically have to fly to the Canary Islands to see starlight.

reply
airstrike
5 months ago
[-]
One step closer to the Matrix
reply
novosel
5 months ago
[-]
"The envisioned indoor farm would grow fruits and vegetables inside a multilevel warehouse, maximizing yield per acre while minimizing environmental impacts through a controlled, closed-loop system."
reply
rUsHeYaFuBu
5 months ago
[-]
What about indoor vertical farming? Or disease killing pollinators? Or climate change doing the same?
reply
rixthefox
5 months ago
[-]
Yeah, all our pollution and climate change is disrupting ecosystems.

Our only way to ensure survival on and off the planet is to mimic their actions (in this case pollination) to ensure that if we do manage to push more and more species to extinction we have options for being able to continue after they are gone.

reply
getwiththeprog
5 months ago
[-]
Or we could plant some bushes, trees and wildflower meadows inbetween fields?
reply
hulitu
5 months ago
[-]
With no economic value ? Definitely no. /s
reply
ge96
5 months ago
[-]
Would be curious how the "solenoid" works, does it pull in/out towards the center line and the wings flap somehow like on a hinge?
reply
ge96
5 months ago
[-]
turns out it's not a solenoid it's more like a piece of rubber/flexing tube
reply
aspenmayer
5 months ago
[-]
Found this video on the MIT Robotics YouTube page of some of the robots Kevin Chen was working on from a year ago, but I couldn’t find any videos of the new on on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xmrDK_w0Yog

The paper itself links to some videos but I haven’t looked at those yet.

reply
westurner
5 months ago
[-]
Is there robo-beekeeping with or without humanoid robots?

/? Robo beekeeping: https://www.google.com/search?q=robo+beekeeping

Beekeeping: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beekeeping

FWIU bees like clover (and dandelions are their spring food source), which we typically kill with broadleaf herbicide for lawncare.

From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38158625 :

> Is it possible to create a lawn weed killer (a broadleaf herbicide) that doesn't kill white dutch clover; because bees eat clover (and dandelions) and bees are essential?"

> [ Dandelion rubber is a sustainable alternative to microplastic tires ]

Pesticide toxicity to bees: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pesticide_toxicity_to_bees :

> Pesticides, especially neonicotinoids, have been investigated in relation to risks for bees such as Colony Collapse Disorder. A 2018 review by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) concluded that most uses of neonicotinoid pesticides such as clothianidin represent a risk to wild bees and honeybees. [5][6] Neonicotinoids have been banned for all outdoor use in the entire European Union since 2018, but has a conditional approval in the U.S. and other parts of the world, where it is widely used. [7][8]

TIL dish soap kills wasps, yellow jackets, hornets nearly on contact.

From https://savethebee.org/garden-weeds-bees-love/ :

> Many are beneficial, like dandelions, milkweed, clover, goldenrod and nettle, for bees and other pollinators.

reply
pilingual
5 months ago
[-]
NHK did a story a couple months ago on a company in Japan called HarvestX that focused on pollinating strawberries using an arm not a drone.

What they learned in their research was the more evenly and completely the pollen was spread, the more idyllic in shape the strawberry.

reply
slibhb
5 months ago
[-]
Right out of Ernst Junger's best book: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Glass_Bees (1957)
reply
bookofjoe
5 months ago
[-]
Ordered it; can't wait till it arrives Saturday. FWIW, I find HN book recommendations/mentions a constant source of mostly arcane titles I'd never come across anywhere else. True for movies as well.
reply
slibhb
5 months ago
[-]
Hope you enjoy it! It's a strange book and the bees in question are a small detail.

I found it presicient (though ultimately wrong) in terms of how it portrays what is essentially a big tech company.

reply
mhb
5 months ago
[-]
So it has the same power deal-breaker as all of these things.
reply
airstrike
5 months ago
[-]
Obligatory Slaughterbots link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-2tpwW0kmU
reply
pr337h4m
5 months ago
[-]
Huh, a hunter-seeker
reply