Show HN: A CSS-Only Terrain Generator
371 points
5 months ago
| 26 comments
| terra.layoutit.com
| HN
senfiaj
5 months ago
[-]
When I turn off JS, it shows a loader instead of the terrain. Is this really CSS-Only? I mean it's still a high achievement even with JS, but was expecting it would also work without JS. This one, for example, truly works without JS https://benjaminaster.com/css-minecraft/ .
reply
arbll
5 months ago
[-]
I'm assuming it's the render engine that is in pure CSS. You could display a static map in CSS but things like the tools to modify the terrain definitely need JS.
reply
psygn89
5 months ago
[-]
You might not need it using the new :has() and different inputs as modifiers. Though that's a lot of :has() and probably would kill performance.
reply
thih9
5 months ago
[-]
I wanted to check if your assumption is correct but I couldn’t find the source code.

Why do you think the renderer is pure css and not e.g. mostly css?

reply
embedding-shape
5 months ago
[-]
The top right button has a "Download code" which gives you a .zip file. That .zip file doesn't have any JS in it, and renders the terrain just like in the online editor, except you can turn off JS and it still works.

Edit: someone else wrote basically the same an hour ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45814791

reply
thih9
5 months ago
[-]
Looks like it’s a “(css-only terrain) generator” - a generator that lets the user create and download a css only terrain.

As opposed to a “css-only (terrain generator)” - a terrain creation studio built with css only.

reply
nightpool
5 months ago
[-]
GP linked an example of a similar project that allowed you to modify the terrain without any JS at all
reply
decimaldesign
5 months ago
[-]
I think what's intended is that the completed and downloaded solution doesn't require any javascript.

Build something then hit the Download Code button - that packaged HTML solution doesn't require any javascript to render locally.

reply
senfiaj
5 months ago
[-]
Yeah, it worked, it seems to be a static rendered html with no interactivity though.
reply
forthwall
5 months ago
[-]
Wow this really feels like roller coaster tycoon!!! (I can see lots of people refer to this to their favorite sim game though)

Great work!

reply
yreg
5 months ago
[-]
I really miss these building games that used an isometric grid. RC Tycoon, Zoo Tycoon, Sim City, TTD, …

Yes, it's less realistic, but it is so pleasant to work with. Everything you build aligns perfectly and if you want, you can neatly fill the entire map.

In comparison, (even with many mods) my Cities Skylines or Planet Coaster creations never look quite right. Building the roads and paths is always awkward and frustrating.

(I've commented this before.)

reply
qingcharles
5 months ago
[-]
As someone who wrote one of those 2D-ish isometric games in the 90s, it was hell. All the problems with trying to render the tiles properly and figure out what tile the user was clicking on when some tiles are semi-transparent etc. The artists need medals though for creating amazing levels with tiny palettes of pieces to work from.

We made it especially hard on ourselves by having 3D characters interact with the 2D tiles:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9UOYps_3eM0

I absolutely adore the look of isometric, though.

reply
accrual
5 months ago
[-]
Starcraft and The Sims 1 as well! Games that would let one rotate the isometric view once blew my mind, it was like going from 2D to 3D.
reply
devmor
5 months ago
[-]
Reminded me quite a bit of Populous[1] as well.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Populous_(video_game)

reply
elyobo
5 months ago
[-]
Came to say this!
reply
andruc
5 months ago
[-]
Funny, my mind went to OpenTTD
reply
mig39
5 months ago
[-]
Both Rollercoaster Tycoon and Transport Tycoon Deluxe (which lives on in openTTD) are by the same author, and use the same engine :-)
reply
lawlessone
5 months ago
[-]
Chris Sawyer, he made them with a tiny magnet that he used to write the games directly to a hard drive.
reply
brendoelfrendo
5 months ago
[-]
I once heard he tickled a butterfly in Brazil to cause a cloud in the UK that diverted a cosmic ray onto his hard drive in the exact right spot to flip the required bit.
reply
hulium
5 months ago
[-]
The biome button graphics are taken from the OpenTTD main menu.
reply
Igrom
5 months ago
[-]
For me, "Briefing" from Ace Combat 2 played back in my head straight away.

https://youtu.be/5uPVGs7bq3s?t=8

reply
lawlessone
5 months ago
[-]
I like it's also really 3d, while looking like older 2.5d games.
reply
worldai
5 months ago
[-]
This is exactly what I thought of
reply
cmiller1
5 months ago
[-]
Lots of javascript for a "css-only" tool. Looks like just the rendering is css-only.
reply
jonahx
5 months ago
[-]
You can open up your terrain in codepen with nothing but CSS/HTML, and it renders fine. It's just not interactive / draggable anymore.

So the JS is only being used, essentially, as a nice UI for configuring your terrain and the camera angle from which it's viewed.

This is still an incredible feat.

reply
bogwog
5 months ago
[-]
I guess it'd be more accurate to call it a "Generator for CSS-Only Terrain", as the generator itself is not CSS-only.
reply
tantalor
5 months ago
[-]
It's a "(CSS-only Terrain) Generator", not a "CSS-only (Terrain Generator)"
reply
91bananas
5 months ago
[-]
reply
embedding-shape
5 months ago
[-]
Not to mention of all of those pesky HTML tags and images, clearly not CSS-only, what a fraud.
reply
cmiller1
5 months ago
[-]
"CSS-only" colloquially tends to mean HTML and CSS without Javascript, sometimes without images.
reply
DonaldPShimoda
5 months ago
[-]
The tone of the parent comment suggests they were writing in jest and are aware that "CSS-only" includes HTML.
reply
MarsIronPI
5 months ago
[-]
Yep. Can confirm this does not work with JS disabled. I'm disappointed by the misleading title.
reply
shermantanktop
5 months ago
[-]
is it a Generator for CSS-Only Terrain? or a CSS-Only Generator which creates Terrain?

We need PEMDAS for English.

reply
Elfener
5 months ago
[-]
Let's use sexpr?

actual meaning -> ((CSS-Only Terrain) Generator)

incorrect interpretation -> (CSS-Only (Terrain Generator))

reply
shermantanktop
5 months ago
[-]
maybe RPN?

actual meaning -> CSS-Only Terrain + Generator +

incorrect interpretation -> CSS-Only + Terrain Generator +

Really we may need BNF here

reply
MarsIronPI
5 months ago
[-]
Loglan anyone?
reply
julius-fx
5 months ago
[-]
This is incredible - looks like SimCity 2000.
reply
lloydatkinson
5 months ago
[-]
Does it? All the tiles are usually a yellow brown aren’t they? 3000 has green land
reply
neogodless
5 months ago
[-]
So funny - I thought the same as the first comment. But yeah memory is a funny thing.

https://kagi.com/proxy/sim-city-2000.png?c=zBh1SYcmKrHnLf7qc...

https://kagi.com/proxy/00001307.jpg?c=vxNARhwMwSpmnHAfYQrnRr...

reply
mikepurvis
5 months ago
[-]
The colouring is brown for SC2000, but the geometry is basically identical; I definitely got the same energy from it.
reply
petepete
5 months ago
[-]
While close to SC2000, it's much closer to Transport Tycoon (OpenTTD).

https://www.openttd.org/screenshots

reply
RugnirViking
5 months ago
[-]
Really reminds me of openttd, especially the sandy border around the water

Looks really cool and runs great on my phone.

Seems like there's some kind of rendering bug in the corners sometimes causing the walls to intersect the grass

reply
mpeg
5 months ago
[-]
Reminds me of Populous!

Very cool

reply
rofko
5 months ago
[-]
Thank you! Populous and Transport Tycoon were two big inspirations for sure :)
reply
drcursor
5 months ago
[-]
Next step Populous in only CSS + JS
reply
chubs
5 months ago
[-]
Also reminded me a lot of simcity 2000. Congrats, it's very neat!
reply
johnh-hn
5 months ago
[-]
You nailed it. Well done!
reply
johnh-hn
5 months ago
[-]
I just came here to say the same thing. The raise and lower tools in particular reminded me of it.

For anyone who hasn't heard of it before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Populous_(video_game)

reply
dylan604
5 months ago
[-]
You guys have sent me down memory lane. Hopefully, I don't forget when I have free time to search, but hopefully I can find this to play in an emulator somewhere. This was the very first game I ever bought even though I didn't have an Amiga but had one that was very accessible.

edit: couldn't wait. did the search. it's very much available to play online. hello rabbit hole...

reply
johnh-hn
5 months ago
[-]
Just in case you never came across it, I think the second game is much better than the first one. Enjoy the nostalgia trip!
reply
linsomniac
5 months ago
[-]
Do tell, I've been wanting to play Populous again for a few years...
reply
dylan604
5 months ago
[-]
dosbox top result in search
reply
bodge5000
5 months ago
[-]
I've used a few terrain generators before but I think this one might be my favourite. Obviously the fact its a "CSS only" demo project restricts things a bit, but its got enough going for it regardless.

It actually comes at a really good time for me, I'm currently trying to make the transition from 2d game dev to 3d and things like this are really helpful.

reply
ModernMech
5 months ago
[-]
This thing is killing my CPU, what's the actual bottleneck here for CSS? Is it the number of elements visible and rendered at once? Is it the calculation engine backing CSS is super slow? Or just that most of the work is being done on the CPU it seems (on my machine, rotating around the map, my integrated GPU goes to 20% but CPU stays around 40-50%).
reply
kachapopopow
5 months ago
[-]
it's effectively a cpu 'renderer' with gpu painter
reply
paulbjensen
5 months ago
[-]
Really cool, especially when I realised you could rotate the terrain and do some zooming as well.
reply
em3rgent0rdr
5 months ago
[-]
Impressive, but there is a noticeable lag after modifying the terrain or moving the camera. Is there a way to know if the browser is using the GPU or CPU for rendering, and is there are way to see the milliseconds per frame?
reply
bob1029
5 months ago
[-]
It looks like a layout/style/composition issue with the browser engine.

In Safari I'm seeing 91% CPU time on paint, 6% on layout, 2% on styles. It looks like it's taking somewhere between 100-200ms on my machine to chunk through a state change each time.

> Is there a way to know if the browser is using the GPU or CPU for rendering, and is there are way to see the milliseconds per frame?

For Safari, you would go to the Web Inspector and navigate to the Timelines tab. Chrome has a similar thing.

reply
EGreg
5 months ago
[-]
Can someone please reimplement something like Warcraft 2 on a mobile web device?

It would be a hit, I’m telling you. Even from 1995.

Some people are still playing it 30 years later, obsessively.

And myth ii by Bungie is a classic too

reply
mock-possum
5 months ago
[-]
The controls would take some serious reworking to make it work on mobile - I could see adding a ‘pause’ feature to give you time to scrub your fingers all over the screen to issue all your unit and build orders, performant pinch to zoom would nearly negate the need for a mini map, lots of reworked GUI for building stuff and managing workers
reply
EGreg
5 months ago
[-]
Anyone made a real-time-strategy engine for tiled games on mobile?
reply
o11c
5 months ago
[-]
Stratagus has an android port at least ...
reply
EGreg
5 months ago
[-]
Oh yes I remembered, wargus exists!

Also Microsoft claims this after buying Blizzard:

Through great teams and great technology, Microsoft and Activision Blizzard will empower players to enjoy the most-immersive franchises, like “Halo” and “Warcraft,” virtually anywhere they want.

https://news.microsoft.com/source/2022/01/18/microsoft-to-ac...

reply
nefarious_ends
5 months ago
[-]
Very cool! Do you think it’s possible to do lakes and waterfalls?
reply
rofko
5 months ago
[-]
Definitely! I'm planning for more landscape features for next versions. I think rivers will be a great addition, and waterfalls/rapids sound really interesting too. In the end it's a matter of adding a few classes and designing some sprites.
reply
kataqatsi
5 months ago
[-]
for those interested in more CSS-Only art, Lynn Fisher makes some neat stuff

https://a.singlediv.com/

reply
w4yai
5 months ago
[-]
I got some rendering issues, but otherwise very cool !

https://i.imgur.com/qT6ozyh.png

Firefox 144.0.2, Windows

reply
rofko
5 months ago
[-]
Thanks for the report! Are you using a dark mode extension by any chance? I’ve seen that happen with Dark Reader in Chrome.
reply
throwaway2037
5 months ago
[-]
It is giving Sega Genesis "Populous" vibes.
reply
ryukoposting
5 months ago
[-]
Dark Reader mutilates the rendered output, but only certain tiles. No clear pattern as to what tiles get mangled. Peculiar.
reply
docmars
5 months ago
[-]
The next obvious step will be SimCity 2000 completely implemented using web tech. One can hope!
reply
stefs
5 months ago
[-]
1. what's a layou tit?

2. does it sometimes raise / lower by 2 units?

3. the "flatten" tool is missing.

reply
ForgetItJake
5 months ago
[-]
Reminds me of RCT, very nice!
reply
hersko
5 months ago
[-]
This is super cool! Wonder how hard it would be to use with an RTS game.
reply
iagorodriguez
5 months ago
[-]
Amazing job by an amazing developer!
reply
cluckindan
5 months ago
[-]
Nice! Now do collision checks ;)
reply
all2
5 months ago
[-]
In CSS?
reply
cluckindan
5 months ago
[-]
Yes.
reply
robertheadley
5 months ago
[-]
This is really cool.
reply
worldai
5 months ago
[-]
Impressive work
reply
jimmydin7
5 months ago
[-]
looks sick! great job :)
reply
OldGreenYodaGPT
5 months ago
[-]
Crazy that vibe coding can make things like this now! 2026 going to be crazy! There is no AI bubble
reply