The Eggstraordinary Fortress
91 points
19 hours ago
| 10 comments
| ahmed1011001.github.io
| HN
MarkusWandel
14 hours ago
[-]
Eggs really don't go bad quickly. It is common knowledge that due to different washing techniques it's safer in Europe than in North America to keep them unrefrigerated (raw), but let's just say a certain spouse of mine is pretty callous about that - a tray of 30 of them from Costco doesn't fit in the fridge right now so it sits around for a few days - and we've had exactly zero issues from all that. And hardboiled eggs don't spoil very fast either. If it had been sitting out for a week, I'd take a careful sniff at it before consuming but overnight is nothing. Edit all this assumes the raw eggs are going to be cooked, of course.
reply
devilbunny
10 hours ago
[-]
You can pasteurize your own eggs if you own an immersion circulator (as used for sous vide). 135F/57C for at least 1h15, per Douglas Baldwin's site (https://douglasbaldwin.com/sous-vide.html#Pasteurized_in_She...). The whites do not whip as quickly per Baldwin, and the whites are a little milky-looking, but for any preparation they are safe, and for those who like runny eggs but have to serve them to people who may be immunocompromised, it's a very good solution. You can poach or cook sunny-side-up and leave the yolk juicy and wet.

A plain egg yolk, served (effectively) raw, is a sauce in itself.

reply
graemep
4 hours ago
[-]
There are some variations between European countries too, although not the washing. When the UK was importing eggs due to shortages caused by bird flu, I recall government warnings about not eating raw eggs because the imported eggs were not as safe, but no warnings about storing them any differently.

So, wherever they were being imported from they were not washed American style (or we would have been warned about storage) but at least some of them were from places that had significantly different standards in some other way.

reply
rsynnott
2 hours ago
[-]
Probably the salmonella vaccine; it's mandatory in much of Europe, but there are a few countries where it's not commonly used and at least one where it's banned.
reply
tomaytotomato
4 hours ago
[-]
Agreed - a boiled egg is absolutely safe after a day. Had many I've "acquired" at hotel breakfast buffets, and left at the bottom of my backpack. Only to consume +1,+2 days later.

I think the author meant well with their security metaphor but overindulged in the classic overthinking engineer and food safety.

reply
ticulatedspline
14 hours ago
[-]
Indeed, eggs are far more shelf stable than most people give them credit for (even washed ones). Though refrigeration helps maintain egg grade. So while your costco eggs may be 100% safe to eat they might be grade B by the time you get to them.
reply
ralfd
2 hours ago
[-]
This gave me a bit of culture shock. Do American children not dye/paint hard-boiled eggs for easter?

Hardboiled eggs are good two weeks at room temperature and 4 weeks in the fridge:

https://www-ndr-de.translate.goog/ratgeber/kochen/warenkunde...

That makes them a good food for (multiday) traveling/hiking too.

reply
oersted
2 hours ago
[-]
> My background is in sterile large molecule manufacturing within biotech, the kind of work where even a single microscopic breach within thousands of gaskets and kilometres of stainless steel can trigger an investigation lasting months or even years.

I would love to learn about such things but there seems to be very little writing about topics like this compared to all kinds of software niches.

What's up with engineers working in industrial contexts? From where I'm standing it seems like they are one of the groups that talk the least about what they do. You hear a lot more about science, law, finance... Is it due to IP issues? Is it a cultural thing? Is it just that I'm not looking in the right places?

reply
TN1ck
16 hours ago
[-]
That egg was totally still edible, even if you pierce it for the cooking, it should be good for at least a few days. If you do it right, it can be weeks. In Germany you can buy cooked eggs in the super market and they are not refrigerated.
reply
D13Fd
15 hours ago
[-]
Even though it had a hole in the shell?

This article was weird, in that he went through the whole thing about how effective the layers are without also mentioning there was a hole through all of them other than the egg white (until the end).

reply
formerly_proven
8 minutes ago
[-]
Yeah, cooked eggs keep for weeks with no refrigeration, despite the hole. At least in temperate climates.
reply
TN1ck
13 hours ago
[-]
That’s true, at least I would have eaten it. I did leave out boiled eggs with holes after cooking them for at least a day in the past. It depends of course, I don’t live in a super humid and hot climate, results may differ there.
reply
masfuerte
12 hours ago
[-]
The egg cooker is a mystery to me. What is the hole for? I hard-boil eggs by heating a pot of water containing the eggs. Why would you puncture the shell?
reply
baruz
11 hours ago
[-]
I do not know about TFA and the egg cooker, but I usually boil the water first so I can pull the eggs out at a specific time (6:30 to 7:00) so the yolk is gooey. When I put an egg into boiling water without putting a hole through to the air sac, I think there's a higher chance that the egg will crack and spew albumen throughout the boiling water.
reply
pverheggen
15 hours ago
[-]
It addresses this in the article, but in countries that wash the bacterial layer off (like the US), they have to be refrigerated. This is to minimize salmonella contamination, EU deals with this by vaccinating hens against salmonella instead.
reply
TN1ck
13 hours ago
[-]
Does the same apply for cooked eggs? I would have thought all bacteria is gone from the shell after the process, making EU and US cooked eggs virtually the same. A short search seems to agree with that.
reply
dekhn
12 hours ago
[-]
it is very, very unlikely that a fully cooked egg that sat out overnight would have enough bacterial growth (and toxin production by bacteria) to represent a threat to a normal person with a typical immune system.

If the egg had bacteria already growing in it (which is also unlikely) then it's possible that enough of the bacterial toxins could accumulate and be inside when you eat it.

There are probably a number of extremely rare scenarios which would modify the situation but this article includes a lot of words and facts only to come to the unlikely conclusion.

reply
tomcam
12 hours ago
[-]
A little off topic, but: we who have chickens know that fresh eggs last for weeks if left unwashed.
reply
xeonmc
11 hours ago
[-]
How long does it take for a chick to hatch from an egg?
reply
croisillon
49 minutes ago
[-]
most chicken eggs (particularly the ones produced for consumption) are not fertilized by a rooster
reply
tomcam
10 hours ago
[-]
About 3 weeks
reply
ndsipa_pomu
3 hours ago
[-]
You don't have to keep chickens to know this - outside of the U.S. eggs aren't washed before being sold as washing removes the antibacterial cuticle which then means that they need to be refrigerated. Seems like a ridiculous idea to me - wash them to make them more likely to spoil, but of course the best solution is to vaccinate the hens to prevent salmonella contamination.
reply
IAmBroom
16 hours ago
[-]
Lots of thinking, from someone apparently experienced with lab testing of anti-germ precautiuons. Zero testing.

Disappointing. He actually has the lab equipment to measure some of his theories about denatured proteins et al.

reply
lbeckman314
12 hours ago
[-]
So one of those egg council creeps got to you too, huh? [0,1]

[0] https://frinkiac.com/video/S06E12/-1x9jGk4guJdUb76ZrC2FbPyug...

[1] https://youtu.be/AHAFMFFQlkI

reply
yapyap
4 hours ago
[-]
Odd, I never refrigerate eggs.
reply
ndsipa_pomu
4 hours ago
[-]
They should only be refrigerated if you live in an egg washing country such as the U.S. as washing will remove some of the antibacterial coating on the outside of the shell. Elsewhere, eggs can be left at room temperature and still be safe to eat for a few weeks.
reply
metalman
2 hours ago
[-]
there are people who look specificly for old eggs , that they then pickle, also there are a wide variety of cultural food practices, probably banned here in the west, that involve eggs and other foods bieng "aged" under certain conditions personaly, I cant eat factory eggs, something in the feed comes through in the eggs and makes me a bit queezy, farm eggs no problem, tried factory eggs a bunch of times blech!,every time.
reply
NedF
14 hours ago
[-]
It would be safe overnight.

Any food can be poison including if it's sealed before a use-by, it's about a percentage which a overnight boiled egg would be lower than for the English word 'safe'.

The claim is cooked eggs don't last as long as normal eggs, what is interesting is what is the percentage/graph?

Boiled Easter eggs are a tradition. You don't hear about mass deaths around Easter unlike rice that's been left out at pre-wedding to wedding parties etc.

reply
quuxplusone
11 hours ago
[-]
Okay, I'll bite: who's dying from wedding rice?
reply
rsynnott
2 hours ago
[-]
The classic one for rice is bacillus cereus (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacillus_cereus#Pathogenesis, specifically the emetic form). That said, while unpleasant, it very rarely kills people.
reply
danparsonson
10 hours ago
[-]
Not the OP, but cooked rice if not properly stored and reheated can lead to food poisoning (Bacillus Cereus is the bug).
reply
ndsipa_pomu
3 hours ago
[-]
https://www.karmactive.com/uk-food-poisoning-cases-rise-due-...

> Rice left at room temperature for more than two hours should be discarded rather than refrigerated.

I believe part of the problem is that re-heating the rice doesn't kill off bacillus cereus so once the rice has been sat around for a couple of hours it can't easily be made safe to eat.

reply