Show HN: A game where you invest into startups from history
41 points
6 days ago
| 17 comments
| startupgambit.com
| HN
hex4def6
1 day ago
[-]
I think the forced countdown is a bit unfriendly, especially when LLM delays eat the majority of that. Perhaps limit it to X questions.

Also, having a min / max funding range (e.g, min 100K, max 500K). I might not want to wager the same on each opportunity.

It might also be interesting to base it off real companies. Scramble the names (Paypal -> CashMate or whatever. Enough that the player doesn't know for sure what company its based on. ATi vs nVidia for eg), and also allow investment at multiple points in time. Pre-crash vs post-crash might yield significantly different ROI outcomes.

reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Thanks for feedback. The successful startups are actually always based of real companies for example ClaritySearch = Google. I'll try to make that part clearer.
reply
oceansky
1 day ago
[-]
Not playable on mobile browser
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Mobile is next!
reply
ivraatiems
1 day ago
[-]
This is a genuinely great use of LLMs/related technology. Dynamic characters you can have conversations with to make game choices more informed is a really cool idea, actually feels original and clever. I really enjoyed playing it.
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Thanks :)
reply
frenchmajesty
1 day ago
[-]
Fun game! My investing strategy is to flush out quickly who's the team, what's the traction, what's unique insight into the market.

Bullshitters have trash or no answers. Killer companies have one of those 3 that is usually very compelling.

reply
volkk
1 day ago
[-]
i've asked who's the team 3 times and always got "can't disclose." i figured this was a limitation of the game. do some answer?
reply
frenchmajesty
1 day ago
[-]
I do get answers. The ones who typically said can't disclose are you full of shit. Crack teams know they're cracked and they will tell you.

"I'm a MIT-trained security engineer; I'm an ex-VP at Paypal, etc..."

reply
jmkd
1 day ago
[-]
Stopped / crashed Dec 31 2005 with $358K return. Cannot proceed. Fun until then.
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Yep the game has only 5 years so far.
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
It was supposed to show "end of demo, please sign up". Welp there goes potential users :D
reply
cjs_ac
1 day ago
[-]
Same - I think that's the end of the game (so far?)
reply
frenchmajesty
1 day ago
[-]
Yea it ends on that date. I cashed out with $622K
reply
anonu
1 day ago
[-]
nice game - but you need a UX designer. Almost abandoned it since I thought it was broken... I just didnt know what I was waiting for or didnt know where to click.
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Noted, actually UX & appearance was the next thing on my TO-DO list
reply
cosmicgadget
1 day ago
[-]
I need to be able to type faster, just got done chatting with Mark and I completely missed the opportunity to invest in Quibi.
reply
achandra03
1 day ago
[-]
Pretty fun! Only complaint is that the responses from the founders take a bit long to load.
reply
lordgrenville
1 day ago
[-]
I tried investing in every pitch I got, which seems to be a positive strategy.
reply
arkensaw
1 day ago
[-]
fun, but it seems if I just invest in everything I don't lose.

I get 3x/4x return on a lot of things but only lose <1x if its a bad investment

reply
rahimnathwani
22 hours ago
[-]
You might like this, which has greater penalties for bad investments: https://tools.encona.com/investor
reply
KomoD
21 hours ago
[-]
At least disclose that it's yours.

Also spam 90% and you're basically guaranteed profit, I did it like 10 times.

reply
mike-gongolidis
1 day ago
[-]
Love it! Very smart! Are all the company names real?
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
No but the successful ones are always inspired by something. Eg. Google, Paypal etc.
reply
Delk
1 day ago
[-]
I'm pretty sure they aren't. I invested in what was obviously Facebook under a different name.
reply
Jordan-117
1 day ago
[-]
I got "SalesForce" at one point.
reply
stevenalowe
1 day ago
[-]
Illegible in Safari on iPhone :(
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Not for long!
reply
asadm
1 day ago
[-]
very cool game! needs some juice.

https://garden.bradwoods.io/notes/design/juice

also, add a leaderboard

reply
andrewrn
1 day ago
[-]
This is pretty fun!
reply
frenchmajesty
1 day ago
[-]
Damn. Now I understand VC's a little better.

Some deals I saw "damn the traction is off the chart" and I didn't even care to ask any question I just threw money at them. I saw one startup named Salesforce, a CRM. I guess hindsight is 20/20 on that one lol. Didn't even read the pitch.

This game is awesome

reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Nice
reply
tglobs
1 day ago
[-]
This is fantastic. It's pretty frustrating for founders to flat-out refuse to answer questions though, I'd probably make that more subtle
reply
vire00
1 day ago
[-]
Thanks. Yeah right now they refuse usually when they don't know the answer. Will polish that part more.
reply
westurner
1 day ago
[-]
Re: backtesting and paper trading: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38908537 :

> pyfolio.tears.create_interesting_times_tear_sheet

reply