Roko's Dancing Basilisk
12 points
3 days ago
| 5 comments
| boston.conman.org
| HN
Terr_
6 hours ago
[-]
Surely I'm not the only one confused by the title? I know the reference "Roko's Basilisk", but I don't follow why that would be "dancing" in relation to... LLM-generated documentation of a codebase. Is the bad documentation its vengeance?

Tangentially, I feel that concept is just a thin layer of paint on a not-too-compelling idea that could happen in any time period: "Thog, what if crazy god get summoned by other cavemen, and it punish all who no help!? Me no take chance!"

reply
dijit
2 hours ago
[-]
Roko’s baselisk exists in other areas.

A company who I used to work for (whom I will not name) purged all management that did not vote in a particular initiative; after said initiative had been in force for a while and put more people in positions of authority (because of said initiative).

Its not just a thought experiment, its a statement about what could happen if you stay politically neutral and fascists take power.

reply
bananaflag
5 hours ago
[-]
> "Thog, what if crazy god get summoned by other cavemen, and it punish all who no help!? Me no take chance!"

The frequently ignored point of Roko's original argument was not that an Unfriendly AI could arise, or even that it would be probable given no preparations against it (these were already said by Yudkwosky), but that even a Yudkowskian Friendly AI might engage in such acausal blackmail stuff.

reply
andai
5 hours ago
[-]
https://www.lesswrong.com/w/rokos-basilisk

Saturday morning infohazard :)

reply
Terr_
4 hours ago
[-]
If any entity engages in unreasonable vengeance, I think "Friendly" is probably the wrong word for it.
reply
stuaxo
19 minutes ago
[-]
Someone is using this tech to generate at least a couple of misleading documentation sites.

I read a few things that are blatantly wrong about Django and other tech.

reply
hrimfaxi
5 hours ago
[-]
reply
riffraff
6 hours ago
[-]
I think deepwiki has been popping up in my search results (e.g. for rust.vim) and I did not initially understand what it is. I am not sure I am happy it appeared there at all.
reply
rustman123
5 hours ago
[-]
I actually blocked deepwiki from all my searches because I was fooled multiple times by the slop into thinking I’m doing something wrong while using the library, only to discover that the „documentation“ showed utter bullshit.
reply