India scraps order to pre-install state-run cyber safety app on smartphones
63 points
3 hours ago
| 7 comments
| bbc.com
| HN
sateesh
12 minutes ago
[-]
The only upshot of this whole saga seems to be an increased awareness (though a small bit) in general public about importance of privacy in the digital world. Most of the media outlets (both English and regional newspapers) provided a prominent coverage of this news.
reply
nephihaha
3 hours ago
[-]
If this means what I think it does, it's good news... But unfortunately, I've a nasty feeling that this will be attempted again and again until it sticks.

We shouldn't call it "cyber safety" as that is a loaded phrase here. Obviously other considerations were part of it.

reply
subscribed
1 hour ago
[-]
They'll wait for UK/AU/EU to enforce one first.

Like with the chat control in the EU now, the foot is already blocking the door

reply
gamesbrainiac
48 minutes ago
[-]
This was never going anywhere and if the Indian government thought it could get away with effectively installing spyware, then they were just self indulgent.
reply
Arnt
2 hours ago
[-]
The app itself seems to be a reinvention of https://www.gsma.com/solutions-and-impact/connectivity-for-g... which is good I suppose, but why not use the original registry?
reply
kamaal
1 hour ago
[-]
Looks like the complaining and protesting on Twitter helped, even if was serious, and some just memes. Somethings to note-

1. Most Indian bureaucracy is clueless about tech things, and just goes by whatever somebody who sounds like techy enough is selling them. Which in this case I'm guessing is a data mining company/lobby.

2. The information derived can be used for various purposes. Plotting election trends, economics, spotting general trends pro/against politics and other nefarious causes. etc.

3. Spying.

4. Using information to go after political opponents.

5. Demographic targeting, which in Indian context almost always means a pogrom against groups, which other groups don't like.

6. Selling data to commercial entities for better targeting, or even social engineering buying choices etc.

There could be many others. But its kind of nice that it was taken back. Having said this, it will be pushed again at some point when people are busy with a crisis and this will be sold as a fix.

reply
stonecharioteer
26 minutes ago
[-]
https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2198110&re...

Read between the lines?

> Given Sanchar Saathi’s increasing acceptance, Government has decided not to make the pre- installation mandatory for mobile manufacturers.

reply
clot27
17 minutes ago
[-]
outrage works
reply