Apt-bundle: brew bundle for apt
32 points
4 days ago
| 10 comments
| github.com
| HN
curt15
2 hours ago
[-]
Brew got one thing right that no Linux package manager seems to emulate: it doesn't require root for normal operations and even goes so far as to error out if running as root (https://docs.brew.sh/FAQ#why-does-homebrew-say-sudo-is-bad).
reply
hiciu
1 hour ago
[-]
"let's allow any user process to modify my binaries" is not something to be proud of...
reply
pzmarzly
2 hours ago
[-]
It needs world-writtable /opt/homebrew, so I guess a Linux equivalent would be Nix (which IIUC requires writable /nix).

For something that only uses your home folder, I recommend checking out mise https://mise.jdx.dev/

reply
mmarx
45 minutes ago
[-]
In multi-user mode, Nix uses dedicated build users to write to the store. There is also single-user mode, but that also doesn't require a world-writable store.
reply
exploderate
1 hour ago
[-]
Or just homebrew on Linux?
reply
WhyNotHugo
1 hour ago
[-]
apk uses a similar approach by default, and I think it's a wonderful way for a package manager to operate.

Basically, /etc/apk/world keeps a list of explicitly installed packages.

When you manually install a package, it's added to this list, when you manually remove a package, it's removed from the list.

Installation and upgrading (and "fixing) merely ensures that those packages and their dependencies are installed, no more, no less. This also automatically cleans up stale, unused dependencies.

It's a lovely way to get deterministic results. You can just back-up that world file, or copy it to another machine and get the exact same installation.

reply
creshal
58 minutes ago
[-]
apt-mark manual has allowed the same functionality in apt since forever and probably inspired apk's copy of it :)
reply
pzmarzly
4 hours ago
[-]
Looking at internal/commands/install.go, it only installs new packages, but doesn't uninstall removed ones. That's the biggest benefit of Brew bundle gone.

BTW how much of it is vibe coded?

reply
exploderate
2 hours ago
[-]
So, this is better than `dpkg --get-selections/--set-selections`? Oh, because it's partial?
reply
letmeinhere
2 hours ago
[-]
aconfmgr[https://github.com/CyberShadow/aconfmgr] is a kinda similar project for pacman-based distributions.

The difference is that it strives to track all non-user files, (not just packages, and especially /etc), but you can adopt it partially.

reply
Arrowmaster
1 hour ago
[-]
I hate the Aptfile format after looking at it.

The ppa directive hints that this is intended for Ubuntu because otherwise installing PPAs is a great way to break a non Ubuntu distro.

The deb directive uses the old and soon to be deprecated .list file extension. DEB822 format is the replacement.

The key directive adds the key as globally trusted for all repos instead of locking it to a specific repo as recommended by Debian. I think this is required under the new DEB822 repo format.

reply
pamcake
5 hours ago
[-]
Big fan! Was like magic at first but now I have a big bunch of Aptfiles to deal with instead... Currently working on solving that with the next-generation tool apt-bundle-bunch, which has a simple declarative format to manage your apt-bundle projects in an Aptbundlefile. It's already great for agents and Im working with Claude on a curl|sh install for the v1.
reply
Imustaskforhelp
4 hours ago
[-]
> Big fan! Was like magic at first but now I have a big bunch of Aptfiles to deal with instead... Currently working on solving that with the next-generation tool apt-bundle-bunch, which has a simple declarative format to manage your apt-bundle projects in an Aptbundlefile. It's already great for agents and Im working with Claude on a curl|sh install for the v1.

Good luck share the progress and let us know how it goes. Is it similar to nix? but from what I can feel, is intending to be simpler?

reply
jraph
2 hours ago
[-]
This appears to be a Show HN.
reply
jbverschoor
2 hours ago
[-]
Put in my mise.toml :)
reply
lifetimerubyist
5 hours ago
[-]
man the things people come up with to avoid writing bash scripts
reply
yxhuvud
5 hours ago
[-]
Given your username, do you have the same reaction to bundler?
reply
c-hendricks
3 hours ago
[-]
What shell scripts would help here? I love me some shell scripting but always reached for debfoster before falling in love with Pac-Man's `-Qe` and `-Qt`

Edit: oh this aptfile doesn't do the one thing I actually use brew bundle for: cleaning up the mess of leftover packages

reply
seemaze
2 hours ago
[-]
I've been loving the Alpine Package Keeper, especially easily maintaining desired packaging state in /etc/apk/world

https://wiki.alpinelinux.org/wiki/Alpine_Package_Keeper#Worl...

reply
lifetimerubyist
2 hours ago
[-]
What is this tool solving that I can't do with apt+bash already?
reply
c-hendricks
49 minutes ago
[-]
Probably nothing other than the fact that you don't have to maintain it and have less worries about portability, like most command line utilities.

Still, can you share your script?

reply
migmaldo
5 hours ago
[-]
I wish I could upvote this more than once.
reply
SubiculumCode
3 hours ago
[-]
I am having a hard time seeing that the install config isn't just basically bash with some aliases...but I still haven't had my second cup of coffee.
reply