Geologists may have solved mystery of Green River's 'uphill' route
83 points
4 hours ago
| 7 comments
| phys.org
| HN
anthomtb
2 hours ago
[-]
Why does this article have a picture of the Maroon Bells? As opposed to something along Green River or, ideally, the 700m deep canyon being described?
reply
gus_massa
1 hour ago
[-]
reply
indoordin0saur
2 hours ago
[-]
Having recently gotten into watching documentaries or youtube videos of accounts of mountaineering expeditions it's amazing how lazy content creators, film makers and journalists can be when choosing what images or videos to show. You'll get something about climbing a mountain in the Andes and keep getting shown completely misleading pictures of Himalayan mountains, etc.
reply
PyWoody
1 hour ago
[-]
Simple, lazy stuff like that always drives me up the wall.

The HGTV show House Hunters used to be wildly inaccurate with their map location pins. On more than one occasion they'd say a couple is from the Bay Area but when they show the map the location pin would be in LA County. Like, come on. That's not even close.

reply
wil421
1 hour ago
[-]
Darn AI agents, I guess they are still cheaper than interns.
reply
MarkusQ
57 minutes ago
[-]
Sadly, they "learned" it from us. People have been doing this sort of shoddy fill work since the dawn of television (and even earlier if you count wildly misplaced / inaccurate textual descriptions).
reply
terminalshort
46 minutes ago
[-]
Judging by the performance of AI agents at Geoguessr I suspect such errors are almost 100% humans:

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/testing-ais-geoguessr-geniu...

reply
markbnj
2 hours ago
[-]
For people interested in the subject generally I highly recommend John McPhee's anthology "Annals of the Former World." Actually I highly recommend everything John McPhee has written but this is a good start :).
reply
arethuza
1 hour ago
[-]
I can also recommend: "The Earth: An Intimate History" by Richard Fortey
reply
mclaurin10
38 minutes ago
[-]
Second for John McPhee! Also Rising From the Plains.
reply
pengaru
31 minutes ago
[-]
References to his books should carry a warning - something to the effect of:

"may inspire circuitous road trips involving many stops dangerously examining road-cuts on busy interstate highways"

reply
phkahler
11 minutes ago
[-]
What about ice pressing down? The repeated glaciations might have pushed in area down and back up several times over 6 million years. Might have even caused that drip to break off.
reply
gwerbret
23 minutes ago
[-]
reply
sethgrisham
2 hours ago
[-]
The invisible hand of the lithospheric drip
reply
IAmBroom
2 hours ago
[-]
You sly dog.
reply
shermantanktop
2 hours ago
[-]
Fascinating to think of entire mountain ranges moving up and down like the skin on a wobbly pudding.
reply
SideburnsOfDoom
1 hour ago
[-]
And the speed at which it happens:

> a cold, round anomaly about 200 km below the surface.

> By estimating how far the drip had fallen and calculating the speed of its descent, the researchers estimate that the drip broke off between 2 and 5 million years ago.

A few megayears later, the bit that broke off is still falling.

200km in 2m years, I make that in the ballpark of 0.1m per year - a bit less if it's > 2m years, and started below the surface.

reply
namenotrequired
2 hours ago
[-]
Can we take a moment to appreciate that Dr. Adam Smith works at the University of Glasgow?
reply