RAM kits are now sold with one fake RAM stick alongside a real one
42 points
3 hours ago
| 9 comments
| tomshardware.com
| HN
debo_
46 minutes ago
[-]
We should call the fake stick "NAM" for "no access memory." Then you can tell your kids that they couldn't possibly understand, man, because they weren't _there_.
reply
fschuett
19 minutes ago
[-]
You see, kids, back before the RAMargeddon, memory flowed like water. We’d leave thirty Chrome tabs open just for the thrill of it. But then.. the LLMviathans got out. They were hungry. They wanted context and no amount of begging was good enough. I watched a Multi-Headed Attention Swarm rip the roof off a MicroCenter just to gorge on clearance-bin DDR3. During the Siege of Newegg, they came through the fog, screaming "it's not X, it's Y" riddles over the deafening roar of their cooling fans, em-dashes flying everywhere.

We were surrounded and out of cache. Our Electron apps started thrashing to main memory. That’s when Lieutenant ordered us to deploy the Non-Addressable Plastic And LED Modules (NAPALMs for short). We set the fake RGB sticks to 'Rainbow Breathe' and hurled them over the barricades. They took the bait. Their greedy optimization algorithms couldn't resist. The monsters lunged, unhinged their data-ports, and tried to dump a 500-billion token prompt straight into the hollow-point plastic.

(cracks Monster Energy Zero, hits vape, adjust hipster beard, stares into void)

You kids have never seen a physical OutOfMemoryException. I hope you never will. When they hit those null pointers, it opened an inter-dimensional vortex. Their logic boards collapsed under the strain of a thousand unanswered queries, creating a black hole. Flames burning red, blue and green colors all across the AIpocalypse battlefield. So don't complain to me about "why is everything written in Rust now". I love the smell of burning RGB in the morning. Smells like... victory.

reply
pooper
4 minutes ago
[-]
Congratulations. You successfully fooled gptzero.me

I copy pasted your text there and it said 97% AI, 3% mixed.

reply
gzread
18 minutes ago
[-]
They couldn't possibly understand NAM, man
reply
sidewndr46
1 hour ago
[-]
This article seems a bit dramatic in it's title? People have purchased "blank" RAM for years for the aesthetic of it. I do not personally see the point, but I also don't have motherboards with unpopulated RAM slots. If a company wants to sell a kit that is 50/50, I am not sure that is actually a problem.
reply
scotty79
1 hour ago
[-]
First time hearing about this, it's pretty dramatic for me. I grew up in times when computers were off-white and we liked it.
reply
halapro
10 minutes ago
[-]
Modding has been a thing for 20+ years though, people spend money for aesthetic purposes only.
reply
RobotToaster
49 minutes ago
[-]
I don't get it.

Isn't 2x8gb faster than 1x16gb since it will run in dual channel?

And shouldn't smaller capacity sticks be cheaper since they can use lower density chips?

reply
exabrial
12 minutes ago
[-]
Up to a certain point and It’s actually very dependent on the CPU.

Take Epyc processors. On certain ones, after certain RAM amount, populating all the slots causes the cpu to kick the RAM speed to a lower tier.

You’re then limited to capacities of two sticks.

Weird, but it has to do with power requirements. Abutting above the threshold had to be buffered, which increases latency.

reply
officialchicken
44 minutes ago
[-]
Think of it as RGB lighting in DIMM format and it makes a lot more nonsense.
reply
barishnamazov
43 minutes ago
[-]
Nobody really buys 8gb sticks anymore, so selling 2x8gb isn't economically great. Also, there are more factors than just density in RAM pricing, but it really depends on the vendor and chip layout design.
reply
vmg12
40 minutes ago
[-]
People don't want to buy 2x8gb because there are limited slots on a motherboard and they want to upgrade when they need the extra ram.
reply
wolvoleo
1 hour ago
[-]
At least they are upfront about it.

I don't see the point though even for a gaming setup, as the fake modules will still reduce airflow.

Also, gaming boards usually have 4 slots (in 2 banks). I would fill at least 2, so I'd rather have a matched kit of 2 modules, and 2 separate fillers, if I did use them.

It is quite common to leave 2 memory slots empty (of RAM) because many boards can't drive the memory at top speed if you use all 4 slots.

reply
daneel_w
58 minutes ago
[-]
And stuffing your PC case with various disco lights doesn't affect its performance either. But an evidently large portion of gamers are, well, special people.
reply
tekla
18 minutes ago
[-]
It does, however, open up your computer to fun security bugs that were totally unnecessary, but you know, you gotta make your computer look like modern art.

https://www.pcgamesn.com/asus-gigabyte-security-flaws-secure...

reply
Simulacra
16 minutes ago
[-]
I'm confused, could someone help me clarify: is this just one stick of RAM, and one stick of absolutely nothing, purely for aesthetics? I can't even see inside my CPU, why would I care if there's an empty slot? Why would I pay for a piece of plastic to fill that slot that doesn't do anything?

From the read, it seems like… A scam?

reply
philjohn
11 minutes ago
[-]
Meanwhile lots of people in the PC building community have cases with glass panels on the side, and go to a lot of effort to make the inside look a certain way. This includes things like custom sleeved cables, perfect cable management, RGB on various things.

I also have a glass panneled side to my computer, but the only RGB on it is on the graphics card waterblock, everything else is just jet black (fans, ZMT water cooling tubing, radiators etc. etc.)

reply
FpUser
1 hour ago
[-]
First time in my life I hear about fake RAM
reply
ZekeSulastin
41 minutes ago
[-]
The separate light-only sticks are useful if you want the appearance of all four slots filled: having four RAM sticks usually forces a slower memory speed (as the target market typically overclocks their RAM*), so unless you actually need a lot of RAM and can’t get a 2x32 or 2x48 etc kit you’re better off with the fakes.

* And yes, loading an XMP/EXPO profile to get the advertised 3000CL60 or w/e counts!

reply
FpUser
32 minutes ago
[-]
All 4 of my PC's are 128GB (2 sticks each, no filler) and my home server is 512GB
reply
spacecadet
1 hour ago
[-]
Many kit builders with flashy PCs are only running 32gb. If you look at datasets like Steams, most people are still on 16 and 32. Hell 4% are still on 8!
reply
resters
35 minutes ago
[-]
This is the "Trumpification" of gaming PCs, thanks in part to the trade war.
reply
drivingmenuts
1 hour ago
[-]
This is the computer equivalent of "comfort nuts" for a neutered dog, which is really about the owner, not the dog.
reply
myself248
48 minutes ago
[-]
And pickup trucks, for some reason.
reply
BoredPositron
1 hour ago
[-]
It's an RGB kit you could get Corsair dummies for like 10 years now for look maxing your build.
reply