Migrating to the EU
484 points
4 hours ago
| 60 comments
| rz01.org
| HN
darthcloud
1 hour ago
[-]
As a Canadian, I’ve been thinking since last year about migrating to non-US services and applications.

My main goal is simply to avoid giving money or data directly to US corporations. I have no illusions, these non-US services probably still benefit US companies in some ways.

They’re rare, but I’ve consciously decided to stay away from some Canadian alternatives. The main customers of most Canadian tech companies are in the US, and I feel they would happily move there if needed.

I started with this:

Gmail / Drive → Proton Mail / Drive

NameCheap / GoDaddy → Infomaniak

Google Maps → TomTom

Google Chrome → Vivaldi

Google Search → Startpage (Vivaldi default)

GitHub → Codeberg & Codefloe (for private)

I do like Proton Mail. The main thing I hate is how often the app and web versions get out of sync for read and archive states.

I’m really happy with Infomaniak, migrating all my domains was a breeze.

Vivaldi is based on the Chrome codebase, but I really love all the extra customization options. It was a very easy switch.

Startpage took me some time to get used to. It’s not as good as Google, but whatever.

TomTom isn’t great, but it’s not like Maps has been great over the last few years either.

Forgejo is much better than what GitHub has become.

Next, I’m thinking of moving away from Google Photos. I’m considering pCloud for that.

reply
detectivestory
21 minutes ago
[-]
I've moved to pCloud for photos and I've found it to be a good alternative. One frustrating thing is that if you are cycling through your photos on the default pcloud app, they are usually slow to render which can be frustrating. Playing music on the app is also a little frustrating. It works, but it it's not an amazing UX. Other than that I am completely content with pCloud though, and I would recommend it.

One other thing to be made aware of is that the macOS ecosystem seems to be a little hostile towards pCloud and it seems to be fighting a never ending battle in order to the get the remote drive functioning reliably there. It works, but it can be a little annoying at times.

reply
Deeds67
26 minutes ago
[-]
I'm actually working on an open source alternative to Google photos right now. Might be interesting to you: https://opennoodle.de

I've got a demo of it running here, so you can see what it looks like:

https://demo.opennoodle.de

reply
Bombthecat
19 minutes ago
[-]
Immich would be one, if they would allow photo compression... Insane that they don't even allow an option parameter

Edit: oh just saw, it's a fork of immich! Cool!

reply
Deeds67
14 minutes ago
[-]
Go ahead and make a feature request for it, sounds like something I could build soon :)
reply
highmastdon
22 minutes ago
[-]
Fyi, your bottom bar with links isn't responsive causing annoying behaviour with horizontal scroll on mobile phone
reply
Deeds67
18 minutes ago
[-]
Thanks for the hint, I fixed it
reply
commandlinefan
49 minutes ago
[-]
> avoid giving money

You're paying for any of these?

reply
hedora
30 minutes ago
[-]
Most of those services are paid by terrible people when you use them.

Look at their revenue breakdowns.

reply
cicko
57 minutes ago
[-]
Hasn't TomTom completely pivoted to OpenStreetMap? From direct contact, I know that they are very active in OSM communities now.
reply
erikvanoosten
42 seconds ago
[-]
OSM is one of multiple data sources for TomTom.
reply
wolvoleo
1 hour ago
[-]
Yeah I was thinking of getting infomaniak for my mail. I don't really care for the encryption thing of proton (all email comes in in plain text anyway!) and I want to just be able to do plain imap without bridges.

But their stuff just feels a bit weird somehow. I didn't really want to commit yet. I'm glad to hear you had good experiences.

reply
frevib
41 minutes ago
[-]
Proton has mail, calendar, drive, docs, sheets and more coming. Everything is done e2ee where possible. In case of mail, when the peer has no Proton, mail is indeed send plaintext.

Mail is stored e2ee on server, so not even Proton can read it. Proton mail has also made PGP very easy to use. It’s Swiss based and a foundation, not a corporation. They’ve done this so they cannot easily be bought.

It ticks most boxes in terms of privacy and security.

reply
exceptione
6 minutes ago
[-]
> Mail is stored e2ee on server

Exclusively, or do they keep caches around? I am asking since everything is clear text in the webmail. I wonder if they handle the rare case of proton to proton (encrypted) mail differently from regular unencrypted mail. I assume they have to decrypt a master key stored on the server with your password, and then decrypt every encrypted email on the fly on the server, or they have to send the master key to the client side.

Now think that through when you have thousands of searchable e-mails, sorted arbitrarily. I won't say it is impossible, but I think that maintaining plain text indexes rather than encrypted ones are really tempting.

reply
Bombthecat
16 minutes ago
[-]
Proton is moving out of Swiss, because of privacy concerns and new laws...

Just fyi

reply
thejohnconway
1 hour ago
[-]
I'm using it Infomaniak, including their KDrive as a Dropbox replacement (with 2TB of data). I've even used their video conferencing app. No complaints so far. All seems to work just fine.
reply
omnimus
25 minutes ago
[-]
The infomaniak KDrive has also pretty great pricing and surprisingly great linux client (it even supports “online/offline” files.
reply
mentalgear
1 hour ago
[-]
For Photos, consider Ente (e2ee).

Instead of Startpage, try DDG (DuckDuckGo) - been using it now for several years instead of Google as I found no difference in search quality.

reply
wccrawford
54 minutes ago
[-]
Their whole point was to avoid US companies.
reply
Besticle
1 hour ago
[-]
If you're going through all that effort why not migrate to open-source/self-hosted?
reply
kgwxd
47 minutes ago
[-]
Email? The rest of your life will be spent wondering if anyone got your message or if you've missed something important.

Registrar, and search? Not possible.

Maps? Paper would be more practical.

Browser, done.

Git, a lot of extra work for no gain.

reply
bluebarbet
3 minutes ago
[-]
>Maps? Paper would be more practical.

On the contrary, maps are (IMO) one domain where FOSS is genuinely better. OpenStreetMap data is far more detailed than any corporate map, and the available clients (Osmand in particular) are far more powerful.

You-know-who can only compete because of its (admittedly useful) data on businesses. And, alas, because of ignorance among normies, many of whom are still clueless that, for example, for hiking or outdoor wayfinding, there are much better alternatives available.

reply
boringg
29 minutes ago
[-]
This doesn't make a lot of sense:

"They’re rare, but I’ve consciously decided to stay away from some Canadian alternatives. The main customers of most Canadian tech companies are in the US, and I feel they would happily move there if needed."

So in an effort to veer from the US based on idealogical positions you wouldn't support your own countrymen because you think in some future state that said copmany might hypothetically move to the US?

Canadians unable to support Canadians is what everyone around the world should read from this comment. Tall Poppy Syndrome in its purest.

reply
sodapopcan
25 minutes ago
[-]
Agreed, this is a VERY odd statement. There are a bunch of Canadian companies that have been here for a long time. I don't have the data but would DNS and hosting providers like EasyDNS and HostPappa really have primarily US customers?
reply
bluebarbet
18 minutes ago
[-]
>What utter BS

Consider for a moment how you would feel if, after carefully composing and sharing your thoughts in good faith, you received this response.

reply
boringg
15 minutes ago
[-]
Im sorry but saying you won't support your own people because you THINK they MIGHT move to the US is BS (I removed it originally because I toned down my knee jerk reaction but I defend it as you brought it up). I hope OP has enough emotional capability to handle some gentle feedback.

FWIW in case you are unfamiliar with it -- Canada has a history of not supporting its own products and companies - so this sentiment expressed above is tough one to swallow given the exceptional talent and capability of Canadians and some countries efforts to undermine that.

reply
joe_mamba
26 minutes ago
[-]
Isn't it compounded with issue that something like 75% of UW grads move to the US for work?
reply
boringg
12 minutes ago
[-]
Im not sure I follow your point exactly?
reply
ekianjo
1 hour ago
[-]
> Next, I’m thinking of moving away from Google Photos. I’m considering pCloud for that.

Maybe try Immich?

reply
dwayne_dibley
1 hour ago
[-]
Seconded.
reply
dinowars
2 hours ago
[-]
> First, I tried mailbox.org, which I can generally recommend without reservation. Unfortunately, you can’t send emails from any address on your own domain without a workaround

I use mailbox for a long time, one account for 2.50EUR/month with multiple custom domains and I can send emails from any address. To send from a different address the process didn't really seem different than other providers.

From Thunderbird mobile on Android I just add a new sender identity. If I need to send from webmail, similarly I just add a new alternative sender. Are these the workarounds you mentioned?

reply
subzero06
9 minutes ago
[-]
Yea been using mailbox.org for couple months and i can send from any address of my own domain...this is bad article. He probably doesn't know how to.
reply
mentalgear
59 minutes ago
[-]
Have been using mailbox.org with a custom domain (including catch-all wildcard) for the last 5 years or so, so it's definitely possible and as far I remember quite straightforward.
reply
akvadrako
1 hour ago
[-]
I use mailbox for the past few years and I think it's the best option out there. But they have one major issue, which is that anyone can impersonate your domain:

https://userforum-en.mailbox.org/topic/anti-spoofing-for-cus...

reply
solstice
26 minutes ago
[-]
Oof, what a drag
reply
layer8
2 hours ago
[-]
My understanding is that the number of such sender aliases is limited, at most 50 or 250, depending on the plan. There are ways to use a custom domain for sending where you end up using a larger number of localparts fairly quickly, and it would be a hassle to have to manage them, instead of just typing whatever sender you want (or on replies, having the email client automatically use the address from the original email, without having to worry whether it’s still in the set of registered aliases).
reply
tpetry
1 hour ago
[-]
When you have a custom domain you can list @mydomain.com as sending domain allowing you every string before the at character. So that means you could use 50 different domains with infinite adresses on these domains.
reply
v20
2 hours ago
[-]
The limit is only enforced in the web interface. You can send from any alias using any third party email client, and on the website you can configure a catchall mailbox and create a rule to filter out the aliases that receive spam.
reply
patapong
1 hour ago
[-]
Hmmm this looks like a really nice option! Any issues with deliverability?
reply
AndyMcConachie
2 hours ago
[-]
I also use mailbox.org and use my own domain for email. Not sure what issue the author ran into.
reply
scrollop
1 hour ago
[-]
Works for me as well.
reply
dragochat
2 hours ago
[-]
...also migrating AWAY from Fastmail (Australian) and TO an European provider sounds like a very bad idea - I'd kind of want both the US and the EU legally away from my coms at all costs (!)
reply
severino
2 hours ago
[-]
Is it that different? Being Australia in alliances like "Five Eyes" I don't think you can keep your stuff away from the US at least when using Fastmail.

If you want both US & EU away from your data, I suppose you will have to consider things like Yandex Mail, which comes with its own set of problems too, of course :)

reply
atmosx
2 hours ago
[-]
Fastmails servers are in the US IIRC.
reply
sakisv
2 hours ago
[-]
While I agree in principle, I have to remind you (and to myself) that Australia is part of the Five Eyes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes
reply
kioleanu
2 hours ago
[-]
The problem is that, even if Fastmail are Australian, they host exclusively in the US. They state that sure, there is the possibility of interference at the data center level, but they rely on their anti-hacking measures to prevent unlawful access
reply
icfly2
1 hour ago
[-]
Fastmail runs exclusively of AWS in the US.

I looked into this, there are lots of people in forums discussing/ asking for EU based servers.

reply
johannes1234321
1 hour ago
[-]
As EU citizen I at least got some influence into EU policy. A government far away doesn't even have to pretend to care about me.
reply
verisimi
1 hour ago
[-]
You have influence over policy? Wow. What do you do?
reply
johannes1234321
1 hour ago
[-]
The EU has about 450 million citizens, which of course limits my direct vote. Downside of a democracy (EU is a complicated democracy, but still) is that a majority probably has other priorities than me.

However there are many ways to impact policy makers. From individual contact to impact on the public debate. Even a small post here may lead to people considering their vote or contacting a local or EU parliamentarian, which in sum pushes the needle. In the end they are receptive, as they need the votes by the people.

It's long and tedious and not all things go anywhere, but then again: I am just one in 450 millionand for most of those priority is to have a Job which pays the rent and food and thus I have to break it down to be relevant for them.

reply
pschastain
3 hours ago
[-]
How comfortable are you guys with the fact that EU countries allow prosecutors and sometimes even police officers to issue their own search warrants without meaningful judicial review? Some EU courts will not exclude illegally obtained evidence either, so challenging the warrant later on will be pointless.

Oh, and you might be in a reasonable EU country and still be hit with an EIO from one of the unreasonable countries. This is especially concerning given recent ECJ rulings increasingly directing courts in receiving nations to blindly defer to the requesting party when dealing with EAWs, EIOs and similar.

Worth considering when hosting in the EU.

reply
s_dev
2 hours ago
[-]
>How comfortable are you guys with the fact that EU countries allow prosecutors and sometimes even police officers to issue their own search warrants without meaningful judicial review?

This is a hilarious 'just asking questions' concern that doesn't address the complete 180 in direction the US is taking and descending in to authoritarianism while moving against the world order it primarily helped build post WWII while threatening other liberal democracies like Canada and Denmark with invasions.

It's a complete false equivalence. ICE agents have straight up murdered two US citizens in broad daylight without consequence and you're querying the nature of some search warrants in the EU.

reply
copper4eva
1 hour ago
[-]
His comment did not even mention the US. Only critiquing the authoritarianism going on in the EU. One of the issues with modern politics is everyone wants to deflect.
reply
wongarsu
1 hour ago
[-]
I need to host my emails somewhere. This means that you can't reject the EU in isolation, you have to compare it to the alternatives. And the most prevalent alternative is the US

Now of course if somebody has a better alternative that's neither in the EU nor US (nor Russia, or China) that'd be interesting to hear about

reply
rglullis
1 hour ago
[-]
Switzerland, maybe? I've been a happy migadu.com customer for years already.
reply
gusgus01
1 hour ago
[-]
Funny enough, they mention moving to ProtonMail which is at least based out of Switzerland. It makes this whole chain a bit funny, but I don't blame the commenter for not breaking down every service the OP talked about and the OP did shorthand it to "Migrating to the EU", so fair enough.
reply
mariusor
41 minutes ago
[-]
Didn't proton fold like a wet napkin when they were asked for information about their users? What I mean is: Switzerland as a whole is probably the wrong metric...
reply
littlecranky67
11 minutes ago
[-]
Switzerland - as well as EU based providers - have to comply with court orders. And the EU as well as Switzerland issue court orders upon request from friendly foreign states ("Rechtshilfeersuchen" in german) - such as the US.
reply
AdamN
23 minutes ago
[-]
These are also political decisions and the EU is much more powerful politically than Switzerland so if your adversary is the US and they're willing to use lawfare or more than you should probably go with the EU and not Switzerland. Germany is considered one of the most robust legal systems for privacy.

But there is always risk no matter what you do.

reply
dwedge
1 hour ago
[-]
Anywhere you can rent a VPS or dedicated server, install exim or mox or mailcow. Configure dns correctly and you're good to go
reply
elAhmo
57 minutes ago
[-]
In email world, this is as far from 'good to go' as you can get. Good luck getting anyone to read your emails this way.
reply
dwedge
35 minutes ago
[-]
Do you run your email server? I run two, have next to no problems (the key is in setting up DNS correctly, as I mentioned) and keep getting told this by people who have never tried.
reply
butILoveLife
1 hour ago
[-]
Do any of your emails actually make it into an inbox though? I did this for a server and I couldn't even get it to land in spam on gmail.
reply
gadrev
57 minutes ago
[-]
Yes but you may need the IPs to warm up and build some reputation, depending where you setup your server the IPs may be burned. Check logs and reputation with some of the postmaster tools the major providers offer and with the services that allow looking up an IP. senderscore used to be convenient to use now it displays a stupid contact form when you try to check an IP, there are others.

To be honest I haven't done the setup for sending a handful of emails but IPs sending hundreds/thousands per day it's fine as long as you don't start spamming people and get flagged.

reply
dwedge
34 minutes ago
[-]
Yes they do. I wouldn't try it from a residential IP but as long as you run a blacklist check on the IP before you start, and configure DNS correctly, it's generally fine.
reply
ahtihn
1 hour ago
[-]
The post is about moving stuff from US to EU, so it's not like the US is brought up out of nowhere.
reply
surgical_fire
1 hour ago
[-]
The comment does not exist in a vacuum. It exists in a thread where the topic is, eminently, migrating away from US services to EU ones.
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
>The comment does not exist in a vacuum. It exists in a thread where the topic is, eminently, migrating away from US services to EU ones.

Even then, there's no interesting conversation to be had unless we pretend it does.

reply
surgical_fire
1 hour ago
[-]
I, and apparently many others in this thread, disagree.

I personally found some interesting comments here, including but not limited to services based off EU that I can use.

If you find it uninteresting, you should stop wasting your time in it and go do something more productive with your time.

Unless, of course, you just want to do some "concern trolling". You know, the "just asking questions" and "just noticing" behavior.

I'll be charitable and presume you are talking in this thread accidentally, and will find your way to more productive activities instead.

reply
pschastain
58 minutes ago
[-]
lmao

did me explaining obscure European legal frameworks for free hurt your feelings somehow?

reply
krzyk
1 hour ago
[-]
> critiquing the authoritarianism going on in the EU

What?

reply
aleph_minus_one
2 hours ago
[-]
> the complete 180 in direction the US is taking and descending in to authoritarianism

A similar (though currently a little bit less marked) trend can also be observed for the EU and EU countries.

reply
Maxion
1 hour ago
[-]
AFAIK there's no murdering of citizens going on in any EU member country by the same countries government at the moment.
reply
emp-constantine
59 minutes ago
[-]
Ofc not!

We learned from the US and outsourced that to third world countries.

reply
snowpid
29 minutes ago
[-]
for example?
reply
krzyk
1 hour ago
[-]
Trends are various. You had Poland remove rightwing goverment 2 years ago (yes and elect righwing president few months ago). Romania electing a European centric president.

We can go on. EU is not a single country, not a single community of people.

reply
s_dev
1 hour ago
[-]
>(though currently a little bit less marked)

Again this is a false equivalence, 'a little less marked' isn't close to imparting the true state of things and to be honest a little disingenuous.

The EU is not in full motion to dismantle democracy across her 27 states. The US should it not turn this around in the midterms is finished as a liberal democracy.

So 'ah yes but Hungary' doesn't persuade me even though I'll concede it's a problem for the EU. If Tisza is elected in April, Hungary will be on course to turn things around. So you're comparing 1 out of 27 to 50 out of 50 states.

reply
Aurornis
1 hour ago
[-]
> The US should it not turn this around in the midterms is finished as a liberal democracy.

I wish there was an easy way for me to bet against the imminent fall of the United States as predicted by so many internet commenters. I don’t like what the current administration is doing, either, but I would readily bet against all of these “the end is just around the corner” or “the empire is dying” takes in a heartbeat.

reply
s_dev
1 hour ago
[-]
I didn't say the US is finished, I said it was finished as a liberal democracy.

It's already slid in to 'electoral democracy' instead of 'liberal democracy' the difference between the two is how 'rule of law' is prioritised and the balance between checks and balances between institutions is enforced.

https://www.v-dem.net/documents/60/V-dem-dr__2025_lowres.pdf

reply
sunaookami
1 hour ago
[-]
>The EU is not in full motion to dismantle democracy across her 27 states

But it is? They forced Romania to do a re-election because they didn't like the candidate. And they still try to force Chat Control, try to bypass the unanimity rule and the EU commission gives itself more powers every day with authoritian laws like the DSA. As a European, I don't get the USA's EU-fetish. It's not better here than in the US.

reply
krzyk
1 hour ago
[-]
EU did not force Romania. Romania itself annulled them because Russian intervention happened.
reply
nozzlegear
1 hour ago
[-]
> the complete 180 in direction the US is taking and descending in to authoritarianism while moving against the world order

The EU is just one AfD win away from doing the same thing. It's not immune to this issue either, you have the same problem happening right under your noses.

reply
noobermin
12 minutes ago
[-]
Europeans are so blind to how they are essentially on the same path as the US, the US just got there first.
reply
epolanski
16 minutes ago
[-]
Not really.

Most European countries have parliamentary democracies.

It's not a winner-takes-all system ala presidential and semi-presidential republics where effectively individuals:

1. rule without opposition. There's no opposition it's not represented in that branch.

2. rule without even needing support of their own parties. The Italian prime minister or the German chancellor have to fight every day in parliament to have support of their parties and the other parties coalitions.

3. a single individual can claim popular mandate. In parliamentary systems you vote for parties/coalitions, not individuals

There's a reason why this authoritarian trend goes from the Philippines, Nicaragua, to Belarus, to Turkey, to Russia, to most African countries and now US. They are all presidential republics.

The last parliamentary democracy to turn authoritarian has been...Sri Lanka. Almost 50 years ago. Presidential ones? It's basically every year.

Systems with winner-takes-all mechanics do not represent voters, and power is too concentrated.

Parliamentary democracies might be labeled as less efficient, that I can agree, but they have strong antibodies to such people.

See Austria or the Netherlands as examples where strong far right authoritarian-wannabes individuals became prime ministers...and then nothing happened and their governments didn't last.

reply
dbvn
1 hour ago
[-]
Lol what does ICE have to do with a local police officer being able to bully a tech worker into providing your private communications?
reply
pschastain
2 hours ago
[-]
I'm not advertising the US here or trying to troll. I'm an European pointing out things about the European system that many here will not have thought about.

>It's a complete false equivalence. ICE agents have straight up murdered two US citizens in broad daylight without consequence and you're querying the nature of some search warrants in the EU.

Maybe keep your US nonsense to yourself?

reply
y-curious
2 hours ago
[-]
I’m in the US and generally pretty level-headed. Nothing makes me become a red-blooded patriot nationalist temporarily faster than seeing Europeans completely ignore the similarities in our political ills. It always boils down to, “but it’s the good kind of authoritarianism we have that preserves social order!!!” as if that has never failed to produce desired results. Thanks for being much more rational. We have a concerning political trend here in the US, it can’t be denied, but the EU is following in step.
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
Yeah, it's really bizarre how this has to be turned into a competition. We have stupid problems in the EU that don't exist in the US and vice-versa.

The way this particular part of our system works is downright horrifying, but it's exotic enough that very few people (even lawyers) will be familiar with it.

reply
icfly2
1 hour ago
[-]
Sorry what? While there are right wing idiots in various governments in the EU, the Trump admin is on a completely different level. Also the bosses of big tech are clamouring over each other to s** him off.

I’m not particularly patriotic or bothered about nations in general, but the yanks can go take a hike.

reply
dwedge
1 hour ago
[-]
Man this whole article and your comment just makes me picture that meme with the fat guy open-mouth drinking from a pipe labelled "media".

By the way, sex him off? Trying to decipher the number of characters

reply
hvb2
2 hours ago
[-]
Just saying, the vast majority of services people are moving from would be US based given it is where all of big tech comes from. So comparing it to the US is relevant?

If you're trying to say the eu isn't a saint either, sure.

reply
pschastain
2 hours ago
[-]
>If you're trying to say the eu isn't a saint either, sure.

I'm not trying to say anything about anyone else besides the EU. Therefore I'm certainly not trying to compare EU to anyone else.

I am an European pointing out issues with the local system, issues that many commenters here clearly aren't aware of given how many replies seem to think that they'll be just fine as long as they don't host in Hungary.

reply
inferniac
1 hour ago
[-]
"ICE agents have straight up murdered two US citizens in broad daylight"

This is delusionally stupid

reply
accrual
1 hour ago
[-]
Is the commenter the "delusionally stupid" one or did you mean something else?
reply
thesmtsolver2
58 minutes ago
[-]
reply
panda-giddiness
34 minutes ago
[-]
What a disingenuous comparison. The wiki article you've linked ("List of killings by law enforcement officers in Germany") sums to 552 people over the last 100 years. In contrast, the corresponding wiki article on the US ("Lists of killings by law enforcement officers in the United States" [1]) estimates more than 900 deaths per year. Indeed, the number of slayings is so great that the article does not tabulate the sum in a single table (as the German article does) but instead links to separate wiki articles with tabulated results by month.

---

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_killings_by_law_enfor...

reply
pschastain
23 minutes ago
[-]
>The wiki article you've linked ("List of killings by law enforcement officers in Germany") sums to 552 people over the last 100 years

I think we can probably agree that this number is not very accurate.

reply
thesmtsolver2
20 minutes ago
[-]
> 552 people over the last 100 years

What a disingenuous comment. Do we really think that is the case?

You ignored my other link. Imagine the outrage EU would have had if US seized immigrants jewelry. Yet, Denmark gleefully does that.

Funnily, I had friends from Europe participate in the No Kings protest here, while coming from countries that have literal kings.

reply
bigfudge
1 minute ago
[-]
> Funnily, I had friends from Europe participate in the No Kings protest here, while coming from countries that have literal kings.

This is either disingenuous or misunderstands the nature of European constitutional monarchies.

reply
throw0101c
3 hours ago
[-]
> How comfortable are you guys with the fact that EU countries allow prosecutors and sometimes even police officers to issue their own search warrants without meaningful judicial review?

(IANAL.) This was reviewed by the courts themselves:

> The CJEU confirmed that the Belgian, French and Swedish prosecutors were sufficiently independent from the executive to be able to issue EAWs. […]

> […] Public prosecutors will qualify as an issuing judicial authority where two conditions are met: […]

> 2. Second, public prosecutors must be in a position to act in an independent way, specifically with respect to the executive. The CJEU requires that the independence of public prosecutors be organised by a statutory framework and organisational rules that prevent the risk of prosecutors being subject to individual instructions by the executive (as was the case with the German prosecutor). Moreover, the framework must enable prosecutors to assess the necessity and proportionality of issuing an EAW. In the French prosecutor judgment, the CJEU specifically indicated that:

* https://www.fairtrials.org/articles/legal-analysis/can-belgi...

The question that the OP asks is fair enough, but there's a lot of subtly and 'low-level' details on how things operate compared to the high-level question that is being asked. Also depends on where the OP lives and what he's used to: common law (UK/US/CA/etc) and civil law procedures and laws are (AIUI) quite different.

reply
Aerroon
2 hours ago
[-]
For anyone wondering:

EAW = European Arrest Warrant

EIO = European Investigative Order (basically lets different jurisdictions demand information from each other)

CJEU = Court of Justice of the EU (think of it as a supreme court)

reply
stanac
2 hours ago
[-]
Also IANAL: I Am Not A Lawyer. If you really want to guard yourself from a legal standpoint, write the full sentence. "IANAL" could mean anything.

That being said, I am not a lawyer, I am not a legal professional, this is not a legal advice.

reply
Rygian
3 hours ago
[-]
Valid question, which must be put in the context of US-based providers willingly satisfying US out-of-jurisdiction search requests for EU data without even letting the EU know about it. (And when the providers are not willing, they can be forced by U.S. Cloud Act)

https://www.forbes.com/sites/emmawoollacott/2025/07/22/micro...

reply
mongol
2 hours ago
[-]
Sweden is a country like this. It is just the way it is here. It can be abused, sure. But all things considered, I much rather have my things hosted here than in the US.
reply
pschastain
2 hours ago
[-]
Yeah, but you also have Hungary who can decide to do things the same way they're done in Sweden and Finland.
reply
microtonal
2 hours ago
[-]
So don’t host your stuff in Hungary?
reply
icoder
2 hours ago
[-]
Yeah I think this basically answers this entire sub-thread
reply
pschastain
2 hours ago
[-]
Hungary can send an EIO to France or Germany, and the consistent trend has been to reduce the ability of executing states to review these requests.
reply
krzyk
1 hour ago
[-]
Sure, those EIO will be held if Hungary starts applying EIO that it got (e.g. for former Ministry of Justice of Poland which awaits trail, he sits comfortably in Hungary).

Let's hope elections there will change Orban into something saner.

reply
foldr
1 hour ago
[-]
There’s a concerning trend of EIOs issued by Hungary being enforced in France and Germany? What would be an example of this?
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
This is the best I can give you off the top of my head, but look at which countries are the most active in eurojust :) https://www.eurojust.europa.eu/ar2020/data-annex

An LLM can probably find some better links though.

reply
foldr
1 hour ago
[-]
I think you might be missing the ‘concerning’ part. Which specific cases are concerning? I don’t find it inherently concerning that people can’t escape justice by crossing the Hungarian border, Bonnie and Clyde style.
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
Oh no, that's totally up to you. If you're happy with the courts in your country not being able to review the requests sent from Hungary, that's cool. Without transparent judicial review, how could we even know if the cases are concerning?
reply
foldr
22 minutes ago
[-]
EIOs are subject to review by the recipient state. It seems that you can’t point to a single relevant example of a concerning EIO from Hungary.
reply
pschastain
5 minutes ago
[-]
"Subject to review" means little more than "is the form filled correctly?", it certainly does not mean second-guessing by the courts in the executing state.

Like, yeah, your EIO will be rejected if you don't tick any of the crime-category boxes in the form.

reply
ApolloFortyNine
56 minutes ago
[-]
Too explicitly spell it out, op is saying here that if any one of the 27 countries in the EU decides you are breaking one of their laws, they can have 1 of the other 26 enforce an EIO.
reply
pschastain
48 minutes ago
[-]
Which would be perfectly fine if your local jurisdiction could still properly review those foreign requests.
reply
foldr
18 minutes ago
[-]
EIOs are subject to a dual criminality requirement. So it’s not as if arbitrary Hungarian laws can be applied in France via EIOs. And of course, we all know this is not happening, which is why we get radio silence from the people who are ‘concerned’ about this whenever specifics are requested.
reply
pschastain
10 minutes ago
[-]
>EIOs are subject to a dual criminality requirement

Dual criminality requirement only applies to non-Annex D crimes. Which is... not many crimes. You seem awfully confident for someone so ill-informed.

>And of course, we all know this is not happening

How would you know that it isn't happening? EIOs are not public!

reply
mongol
2 hours ago
[-]
In Hungary, sure. But each country has its own jurisdiction.
reply
pschastain
2 hours ago
[-]
Yeah, way to not read the thread.

I'll repeat: EIO

reply
mongol
1 hour ago
[-]
So what? Can you point to a real example where this has been abused or are we discussing hypotheticals?
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
You can look at past ECHR decisions for countless cases of abuse by various national governments.

You can look at the history of EAW related litigation also, it'll probably prove most informative. Executing states used to constantly deny requests due to judicial review, rules were clarified to remove the possibility of judicial review by executing states.

reply
mongol
1 hour ago
[-]
I was expecting you might have a relevant example that applies to this discussion.
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
Writing "EAW abuse" into google finds endless lawyer marketing posts. The facts of the first one I clicked on sound pretty bad!

https://greatjames.co.uk/martin-henley-secures-the-dismissal...

reply
bean469
2 hours ago
[-]
> How comfortable are you guys with the fact that EU countries allow prosecutors and sometimes even police officers to issue their own search warrants without meaningful judicial review?

Just to be clear, according to the DOJ, law enforcement officials in the US can search your home without a warrant if they suspect that you are a "Alien Enemy" [1].

https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25915967-doj-march-1...

reply
squarefoot
2 hours ago
[-]
Don't forget civil forfeiture, which can (an does) happen whether they think you're an enemy or not.

https://ij.org/issues/private-property/civil-forfeiture/freq...

reply
kvuj
2 hours ago
[-]
Wouldn't source that this is happening in 1 of the member states be enough to raise alarms? Why do all of them need to for you to consider this an issue?
reply
rich_sasha
42 minutes ago
[-]
Without disagreeing at all, can you think of a major jurisdiction that's better? US I basically assume everything is searchable without a warrant, if not leaked on a ex-DOGE intern USB stick.

Who else is there with a major infra ecosystem? Russia? China? UK? Not sure these are better than EU. Japan seems quite inward looking.

reply
nottorp
2 hours ago
[-]
US legal protections do not apply to EU citizens keeping their data in the US, do they?

So what's the point of this comparison, since if I host my data in the US they don't need a warrant at all?

reply
PeterStuer
2 hours ago
[-]
The geo-location of where you keep your data is irrelevant to US legal reach.
reply
paganel
1 hour ago
[-]
They don't, they don't even apply to EU citizens keeping their (our, in fact) data on our (EU's servers) if what we're doing happens to cross some interests of the US Government. I mean, there are some legal "protections" in place for that, but notice the quotes. Thinking otherwise is delusional, but, hey, people should be allowed to enjoy the liberty of their slightly larger iron bird-cage.
reply
FabCH
1 hour ago
[-]
You are technically correct but seem to be applying common law standards to civil law countries.

Unlike common law judiciary, civil law judiciary in and of itself has investigatory powers and judges don’t just hear arguments but can order their own investigations and are significantly more independent than in common law.

This can cut both ways, yes in theory the judge can accept evidence the prosecution obtained illegally, but the judges can also call the prosecutions bluff and call their own witnesses or order an independent expert to provide their own opinion, even if defense is unable to.

reply
alpineman
3 hours ago
[-]
At least there is still the rule of law and democracy in the EU
reply
pschastain
3 hours ago
[-]
Is there really? Governments routinely go against the ECHR and the ECJ, and do nothing to rectify past violations when ruled against.

On a national level, sure.

reply
pjc50
2 hours ago
[-]
Which cases are you talking about? Compliance with actual court rulings is pretty high.
reply
pschastain
2 hours ago
[-]
Want a particularly egregious example? Here: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex:62...

Police in many EU countries was systematically searching suspects phones without mandatory due process. This was prima facie illegal, everyone involved knew it. They did it regardless.

Yeah, this decision eventually resulted in many governments issuing new guidance, and some countries rewriting their national legislation. Is that a big victory for the rule of law? I think not, the national governments should not be knowingly violating the ECHR in the first place.

reply
rithdmc
2 hours ago
[-]
It took Ireland years from an ECHR ruling to rule buggery was not unlawful, and Ireland was given a special exemption to the EUs abortion laws which remained in place for 26 years.
reply
input_sh
3 hours ago
[-]
Considering who we're comparing it to when discussing this topic: absolutely. Not even a question.

Anyone claiming otherwise is delusional at best.

reply
Levitz
2 hours ago
[-]
A whole lot of websites are inaccessible from my country when there's football on, due to a judicial order meant to curb piracy.

The whole deal with Chat Control is also not to be forgotten. I do think you guys see this place with rose tinted glasses sometimes.

reply
input_sh
2 hours ago
[-]
Does that football scenario mean that the rule of law doesn't exist or that it does exist and is being enforced?

I agree with you that both of those laws are stupid, but that's a completely separate discussion to what I'm claiming above.

reply
pschastain
18 minutes ago
[-]
Depends on how you interpret the ECHR.

Does it allow blocking half the internet during football games?

It almost certainly does not: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-115705%...

AFAIU this is common because lower courts often deliberately choose to not try to interpret ECHR, leaving that for appeals courts.

reply
rafram
2 hours ago
[-]
The baseline level of freedom of speech in the EU, in particular, is much, much worse than in the US. We’re talking about a group of countries with active, enforced blasphemy laws! Completely unthinkable for Americans.
reply
microtonal
2 hours ago
[-]
The US is at position 57 in the world free speech index. Virtually all EU countries do better and a bunch are top 10:

https://rsf.org/en/index

American exceptionalism doesn’t seem to know boundaries.

reply
nozzlegear
1 hour ago
[-]
You linked to a site about press freedom, which is a subset of free speech and not generally what Americans are talking about when they talk about freedom of speech.
reply
dudefeliciano
4 minutes ago
[-]
"Congress shall make no law...prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press."

that does not imply one being the subset of the other to me, if anything they are clearly defined and therefore clearly separate.

Trump refuses to answer simple questions and attacks and mocks reporters, that's if they're lucky and he doesn't directly sue them for millions/billions. Hell, the white house banned Associated Press. Is that free speech or freedom of the press?

reply
Bewelge
1 hour ago
[-]
Boiling down the different approaches to freedom of speech to "The baseline level is higher/lower", has always been a pretty simplistic (and if you would actually delve into the topic a little, flat out wrong) view .

Freedom of speech is not absolute. Neither in Europe nor in the US. Both effectively have rules restricting certain speech. For example, speech that may harm others, such as inciting violence or maybe the most famous example: "Shouting FIRE in a full venue".

European countries tend to spell out these restrictions more explicitly. It's completely reasonable to disagree with these restrictions. But the simple existence of them shouldn't lead you to the conclusion that one is "more freedom of speech" than the other.

And at last I want to add, that that is how it's been historically. Sadly, the recent developments in US show pretty well how freedom of speech cannot be measured by "How many specific laws are there about things I cannot say?".

reply
dudefeliciano
2 hours ago
[-]
> freedom of speech

Oh please. There's free speech without a free press (US ranks 57/190, behind Sierra Leone) people are just amplifying the same BS they heard from some ignorant influencer. I would argue even your idea of "active enforced blasphemy laws" shows that. That's worse than useless, that is detrimental to a society (case in point, the current president and his whole cabinet).

https://rsf.org/en/index

reply
raincole
2 hours ago
[-]
The more I learn about EU's system the more I realize American exceptionalism is just stating facts.
reply
this_user
2 hours ago
[-]
The EU is really more middle-of-the-road in most things, while the US tends to be more extreme: more really good ideas, but also more really bad ideas. But that is also the result of the EU being largely controlled by bureaucrats and compliance officers instead of real leaders.
reply
haspok
1 hour ago
[-]
Is it not true that when entering the US you are required to show all your social media content on request, and if there is anything negative about the current administration, you can be denied entry (if you are lucky, and not detained for an indefinite amount of time)?

Truly exceptional indeed. You are basically on par with China.

reply
prmoustache
56 minutes ago
[-]
Do they really do that and what do they do when you say you don't have one? Do they believe you or not having one is as suspicious as having one with the content they don't like?
reply
johncoltrane
32 minutes ago
[-]
FWIW, you don't have to do any of that to enter China.
reply
krzyk
1 hour ago
[-]
Yeah. Try to enter US as EU citizen and see how good it is. Immigration officers are in bad mood (to say lightly).
reply
nozzlegear
1 hour ago
[-]
For now – the EU is one AfD win away from following in America's footsteps.
reply
krzyk
1 hour ago
[-]
AfD is a party in single country in EU.
reply
nozzlegear
1 hour ago
[-]
AfD is a far right populist party in the EU's biggest economic powerhouse country, whose explicit goals are to leave the EU (they probably can't due to the German constitution), exit the eurozone, withdraw from the Paris climate deal, leave NATO, and cozy up with Russia.

It's not hard to imagine what kind of damage they could do to the EU if they took power in Germany and started working with Hungary to block EU legislation, veto sanctions, defund programs, etc.

reply
andix
3 hours ago
[-]
No system is perfect. It's more a theoretical risk for now, if you're not running a shady business.
reply
noosphr
3 hours ago
[-]
The police will of course decide if you are running a shady business.
reply
rithdmc
2 hours ago
[-]
reply
heavyset_go
1 hour ago
[-]
> What Is An Administrative Warrant?

> An administrative warrant is a legal document issued by a government agency, rather than a court, that authorizes the agency to take specific actions such as conducting inspections, searches, or seizing property. Unlike judicial warrants, administrative warrants are frequently issued on less than probable cause of a crime.

> Administrative warrants are typically used for regulatory or civil enforcement purposes and allow agencies to enforce rules and regulations within their jurisdiction, such as health inspections, building code enforcement, or immigration-related actions.

> The problem with administrative warrants is that they make the agency both the prosecutor and the judge in the very same matter. The entire point of having agencies go to court for a warrant is because courts are an independent branch with an independent mission. Rather than solely focusing on identifying and prosecuting violations of law, courts seek to check agency errors and overreach. When the very same agency that wants to execute a warrant is the one deciding whether it issues, those checks disappear, and Americans’ security pays the price.

https://ij.org/issues/ijs-project-on-the-4th-amendment/admin...

reply
mafuy
25 minutes ago
[-]
This account is sockpuppeting. They are not participating on this site in good faith.
reply
zulban
1 hour ago
[-]
Not comfortable. But making choices in the real world is about choosing the best option, not the perfect option.
reply
PurpleRamen
1 hour ago
[-]
As long as you stay away from questionable behaviour, there is very little chance to encounter the police in the EU or having problems with your privacy. USA is different in that regard. Your existence can be a problem. Or monetary interests will risk your privacy to whoever wants to make money with you.

EU is not perfect, but saver than the USA in those matters (if you want to only invest a reasonable amount of effort and money), which is kinda the point here, isn't it?

reply
pschastain
21 seconds ago
[-]
EU is not a single uniform blob. There are neighbourhoods where you have to worry about being shot, and there are neighbourhoods where people leave their keys inside their cars.
reply
pjc50
2 hours ago
[-]
How much is this a practical rather than theoretical problem?

One of the problems with being on the US Internet is that we get lots of coverage of US police overreach and much less coverage of EU police overreach. That could have one of three causes:

- actual incidence is low

- it's not being reported

- it is being reported, but doesn't generate discourse

(And the counter option: sometimes when you do hear about it, it's been laundered through weird US right-wing politics, like almost anything anyone says about Sweden)

reply
aleph_minus_one
2 hours ago
[-]
> That could have one of three causes:

> - actual incidence is low

> - it's not being reported

> - it is being reported, but doesn't generate discourse

Fourth possible cause:

- the EU has 24 official languages

i.e. when it is reported, the number of people who are actually capable of understanding the reporting is only a fraction and rather localized.

reply
watwut
1 hour ago
[-]
> Some EU courts will not exclude illegally obtained evidence either, so challenging the warrant later on will be pointless.

Generally speaking, I trust EU countries criminal systems more then USA one. USA one is too procedure oriented - like for example with this rule.

Unlike in USA, in general European cops and prosecutors can be punished when they do illegal stuff. That provides better protection then the pretend fairness rule you just cited.

reply
danilocesar
38 minutes ago
[-]
Whataboutyism much?
reply
pschastain
33 minutes ago
[-]
[Tears of Joy Emoji][Loudly Crying Face Emoji][Loudly Crying Face Emoji][Loudly Crying Face Emoji]
reply
kgwxd
30 minutes ago
[-]
Sounds terrible. Guess we should all just accept the worst of the worst and shut up?
reply
deaux
3 hours ago
[-]
This isn't a downside against EU services when compared to the US, so what are you actually suggesting? Don't just vaguely hint at stuff. Should we be moving to Singaporean services? Oh shit, similar concerns there. Okay, where do you suggest we move? If you don't have any suggestions then there's little substance behind what you're saying.
reply
pschastain
3 hours ago
[-]
>This isn't a point against EU services compared to the US

In the US the cops actually need a search warrant signed by a judge. In the EU they only sometimes need one.

>Should we be moving to Singaporean services? Oh shit, similar concerns there

Really? I've always been under the impression that it is courts who issue search warrants in Singapore, not the police or prosecutors.

reply
not_that_d
2 hours ago
[-]
Does ICE needs something?
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
Internal combustion engine? Hydrocarbons, I guess.
reply
generic92034
1 hour ago
[-]
A judge of a secret court, which are known to never deny any request?
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
This is simply not correct. Very few "cops" in the US can go to any kind of secret courts.

Also, what you're describing is still infinitely better than the European system! The cops get to issue the warrants themselves.

reply
generic92034
1 hour ago
[-]
With any number of intelligence services in the USA I would not really be calmed by the prospect that an ordinary cop cannot do that.

What you are claiming about European cops is also not uniformly true. A German police officer cannot "just" self-issue a search warrant.

reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
>What you are claiming about European cops is also not uniformly true. A German police officer cannot "just" self-issue a search warrant.

Yes. The more worrying situation is that Hungary can just decide that their police officers can self-issue search warrants, and then send those around the EU in the form of EIOs.

reply
generic92034
1 hour ago
[-]
This is more of a theoretical concern, though.
reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
Do you feel the random EAW case described by this London law firm is also a theoretical concern? https://greatjames.co.uk/martin-henley-secures-the-dismissal...
reply
generic92034
51 minutes ago
[-]
That delay is concerning, obviously. But how should we judge that, without any further insights?

However, usually it works more like this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carles_Puigdemont#Arrest_in_Ge...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carles_Puigdemont#Arrest_in_It...

Usually LE in European countries will not respect warrants from another country if it does not make sense in the local jurisdiction as well.

reply
pschastain
41 minutes ago
[-]
Germany agreed to extradite Puigdemont, Spain did not want him. Perhaps because they wouldn't have been able to prosecute him for rebellion?

Rebellion is not one of the EAW listed offenses, so it would require German approval. Same is not true for most crimes.

Italy? I assume the prosecutor there told the Spanish there's no way the Rebellion will stick, and the Spanish told the Italians to just drop it.

I assume they'll keep him listed on the SIS in case they get a hit in some friendlier jurisdiction.

>Usually LE in European countries will not respect warrants from another country if it does not make sense in the local jurisdiction as well.

This is incorrect and goes explicitly against the intent of the relevant frameworks.

reply
shevy-java
2 hours ago
[-]
> you might be in a reasonable EU country and still be hit with an EIO from one of the unreasonable countries.

Are you certain this has happened? I never heard that happen in central Europe. I am pretty certain legislation of other countries is irrelevant, unless it would be an EU regulation - and I am unaware of an EU regulation that could bypass local laws and that has not been made a EU law. Which EU law specifically do you refer to?

reply
pschastain
24 minutes ago
[-]
reply
surgical_fire
3 hours ago
[-]
Generally comfortable.

While the EIO is s controversial instrument (I particularly dislike the excessive power it gives to authorities in issuing countries and the inability to question the warrant), it at least is something that happens as part of a judicial process.

I'm certainly more comfortable with it than being subject to the whims of the US government and its 3 letter agencies.

That said, yeah, EIO in the shape it exists is bad.

reply
pschastain
2 hours ago
[-]
>it at least is something that happens as part of a judicial process

Only sort of, because some countries have very weird ideas of what a "judicial process" is.

>I'm certainly more comfortable with it than being subject to the whims of the US government and its 3 letter agencies.

That's fair, but I think it's a mistake. In the worst case the European system grants a village cop in another country the authority to conduct extremely intrusive surveillance on you.

Criminals can easily co-opt this system and steal your crypto or whatever, a far more realistic threat for most people than the NSA.

reply
surgical_fire
1 hour ago
[-]
> That's fair, but I think it's a mistake

I obviously don't share the sentiment.

> village cop in another country the authority to conduct extremely intrusive surveillance on you.

> far more realistic threat for most people than the NSA.

If you think some policeman in a rural Frech village is a bigger threat to your freedom than NSA or other 3-letter agencies from the USA, we can all see who is mistaken in evaluating threats.

> Criminals can easily co-opt this system and steal your crypto or whatever

I don't want to say anything, I just wanted to highlight this bit because it made me giggle.

reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
>If you think some policeman in a rural Frech village is a bigger threat to your freedom than NSA or other 3-letter agencies from the USA, we can all see who is mistaken in evaluating threats.

Just like the random mugger on the streets of Paris is a far bigger threat to my life and limb than the US with their drones.

You're talking from an ideological perspective, I'm looking at this from a rather more practical angle. It's very possible that your line of thinking leads to a better outcome than mine, or perhaps it doesn't.

>I don't want to say anything, I just wanted to highlight this bit because it made me giggle.

It's really not that funny, cryptocurrency thieves have been bribing cops to rob people at gunpoint https://krebsonsecurity.com/2024/09/crooked-cops-stolen-lapt...

Now you can bribe a village cop in Hungary or Romania, and have the French cops do your bidding. This is totally gonna end well!

reply
surgical_fire
1 hour ago
[-]
> You're talking from an ideological perspective

Given your participation in this whole discussion, that was pretty cute.

There nothing else here even worth addressing. This conversation is a waste of time, for both of us.

Have a wonderful rest of your day.

reply
pschastain
1 hour ago
[-]
Having been personally touched by this, I see this as an entirely practical and not ideological issue.

It's harder for me to worry about the NSA than people who have already negatively impacted me in the past.

reply
dangus
2 hours ago
[-]
Maybe the motivation is more to stop giving American big tech MAGA fascists money rather than any kind of gain in privacy/security against state level law enforcement.
reply
_pdp_
3 hours ago
[-]
Our company started migrating our tech stack from USA to EU. We are about 90% there with a few small dependencies that could be resolved but we have not yet tackled.
reply
flowerthoughts
2 hours ago
[-]
Could you summarize the easy and hard aspects? Have you had any unexpected benefits or downsides?
reply
deaux
3 hours ago
[-]
https://bunny.net/ seems solid as a Cloudflare and S3 replacement. I'm not affiliated but they deserve more mentions in these threads.
reply
christophilus
2 hours ago
[-]
Used them in my last project for around 5 years. They were boring in a good way and inexpensive.
reply
recroad
2 hours ago
[-]
I use them too. Highly recommend. Have never had an issue with them.
reply
awongh
56 minutes ago
[-]
> The reasons for this are [...] improved data protection.

Didn't the Snowden leaks just prove that the NSA is listening to most things anyway?

I suppose this has more to do with the specific case of a lower-level agency being able to access your data, rather than it being actually secure?

I get that people would be concerned about that scenario, but also it seems like a little bit of hair-splitting.

reply
BrunoBernardino
2 hours ago
[-]
For search, I'd suggest Ecosia [1] or Qwant [2] if you don't mind ads, or Uruky [3] if you don't want them (full disclosure, I've created Uruky with my wife).

[1]: https://ecosia.org

[2]: https://qwant.com

[3]: https://uruky.com

reply
eino
7 minutes ago
[-]
Thanks, uruky sounds quite promising, giving it a try
reply
axegon_
3 hours ago
[-]
I've migrated just about everything I was relying on a while back. Not only that but I've self-hosted just about everything, with the exception of my email and I've moved whatever I have public on github to codeberg. With the exception of github pages, though I plan on doing that too, when I find motivation to going through the tedious DNS management. I've been on and off on qwant and ecosia for search(lately ecosia has been stepping up their game it seems). But I am considering switching over to searxng, I just want to put it behind a squid proxy somewhere remote, away from my apartment.
reply
vertnerd
3 hours ago
[-]
Used Chromebooks are plentiful and cheap on eBay and many of them are easy to convert to Linux using the tools and instructions at https://docs.mrchromebox.tech/. I used to have a house full of Chromebooks, but now all but one of them are Linux laptops. My favorite is the Acer CP713 because it comes in flavors with lots of RAM and drive space. I also prefer the convertible touchscreen models because they can go on a shelf and make cheap and attractive Home Assistant dashboards.
reply
bluebarbet
2 hours ago
[-]
You seem to know what you're talking about. I used a cheapie Taiwanese Intel netbook for years, on Linux, with great success. When it came to replace it, there was nothing left in that niche (i.e. small and cheap) except ARM Chromebooks with (apparently) locked bootloaders. So I reluctantly bought a heavy and expensive Intel laptop.

Was I wrong to assume that the average big-box-store Chromebook cannot be jailbroken, or has only driverless hardware, or are things changing here? If the latter, surely this opens a boulevard for Linux? Any insight much appreciated.

reply
wraptile
3 hours ago
[-]
You can also get a refurbished thinkpad with Ryzen and 16gb of ram for 400€ or so on european Ebay.
reply
dangus
2 hours ago
[-]
I never understood why bother with these.

You get a dealbreaker keyboard because of the lack of an alt key and you don’t even save much money for the effort of working around the Chromebook restrictions. A laptop originally sold with Windows is so much more straightforward to work with.

I’d just grab something like an HP EliteBook 840 G10 on eBay. Around $300, upgradable RAM and SSD, and reasonably recent. Relatively modern/attractive aluminum build.

Or I’m sure there’s some other 2-in-1 not-Chromebook convertible model you can grab if you need the touch screen.

reply
dragochat
2 hours ago
[-]
how about the OPPOSITE problem: _anyone knows of any non-EU AND non-US email providers_? with email accounts as the roots of trust for many things, i'd really wanna know how can I get a trustworthy one not-attached to eithern an unstable system (US), or a very overregulating one like the EU juristictions...

and ofc, non-CN too

reply
pavlov
2 hours ago
[-]
So where do you want to host your email?

Name a country and it probably has its own problems: some combination of instability, corruption, authoritarian governments, collaboration with the US and EU governments that you want to escape…

ProtonMail is in Switzerland, so it’s perhaps the best mainstream bet. But the Swiss are absolutely not immune to US and EU pressure.

reply
lynx97
2 hours ago
[-]
Isn't Proton planning to move to .de?
reply
groguzt
13 minutes ago
[-]
Proton is in Switzerland, which is not part of EU
reply
keybits
1 hour ago
[-]
Runbox are a good option - company and servers in Norway: https://runbox.com/

Been around since 2000. They're also working on JMAP support and are the top financial contributor to the Stalwart mail server (https://opencollective.com/stalwart) so I think they'll have a more compelling offering soon.

Also worth keeping an eye on Thunderbird pro which will also use Stalwart: https://www.tb.pro/en-US/

reply
stingraycharles
2 hours ago
[-]
Singapore, Japan have reliable ISPs.
reply
lmz
1 hour ago
[-]
If the goal is to stay away from US or European influence then the Russians would be a better bet.
reply
stingraycharles
1 hour ago
[-]
Yes but that has the same downsides as China.
reply
tbihl
44 minutes ago
[-]
And that's pretty much the thread. You're either subject to a large power's jurisdiction or subject to a jurisdiction whose sovereignty is at the pleasure of large powers... Pick a threat model, plan appropriately, and keep things in perspective.
reply
PeterStuer
2 hours ago
[-]
I'm using Zoho (Indian company, hosted in Europe). Maybe not perfect from a geopolitical pov, but it will do for now.
reply
PurpleRamen
1 hour ago
[-]
> how about the OPPOSITE problem: _anyone knows of any non-EU AND non-US email providers_?

Yes, your own server at home. All countries have fundamentally the same problems, so you will have everywhere the same tradeoffs as a customer. So it really depends on what your specific circumstances and requirements are. If laws are your problem, then stay away from countries where you break them; otherwise, just don't go where they will sell your data for any random penny.

> or a very overregulating one like the EU juristictions...

WTF is this kind of demand? Those regulations do not concern you as a user, but can be very beneficial for you, don't you understand this?

reply
petesergeant
2 hours ago
[-]
For email and calendaring, Fastmail, although Her Majesty’s Australian government has strong overreach instincts.
reply
lonelyasacloud
2 hours ago
[-]
> For email and calendaring, Fastmail, although Her Majesty’s Australian government has strong overreach instincts.

The Queen died of 8th September 2022.

reply
dragochat
2 hours ago
[-]
...would those "overreach instinct" expand to "handing over access an overreaching and likely corrupt EU or US prosecutor"? (I don't care about 5eyes etc, spyies will spy me, I just don't want stuff to be easily and unexpectedly draggable in a court case, or am email used as bolt-key to access other things to get blocked by a prosecutor's regulation...)
reply
ffsm8
2 hours ago
[-]
If your threat model includes the USA government then you can only go with obscurity, honestly - preferably self hosted with a completely locked down system that cannot initiate any network communication besides on the relevant mail protocol ports, completely immutable filesystem beyond the mail data with encryption at rest

And with all of that they'll still be able to pwn you through network equipment which relays your mail, eg some router or switch which they backdoored and mirrors all traffic to their datacenter.

reply
tbihl
42 minutes ago
[-]
>If your threat model includes the USA government then you can only go with obscurity, honestly

Or move to Russia. Not recommending, just saying

reply
realusername
2 hours ago
[-]
Fastmail is australian
reply
roelschroeven
2 hours ago
[-]
But their servers are in the US.
reply
dangus
2 hours ago
[-]
lol, you want trustworthy stability without “too many” regulations. Good luck with that.

I’m not sure you know what instability means if you think the US is unstable. If anything, the fact that the dumbest person on the planet is in charge of the United States and the country still functions as well as it does proves a lot about the stability of the USA. The country runs on geopolitical easy mode.

Maybe there’s a libertarian fantasy novel where you can host your services.

reply
I_am_tiberius
3 hours ago
[-]
Codeberg is only for FOSS projects. Is there some good European hosting provider for git? I really don't want to self host git.
reply
petcat
3 hours ago
[-]
devault made sourcehut which I think is hosted in the netherlands

https://sr.ht

I tried it once, it's very opinionated and may not be suitable for what a lot of people think of when they're coming from something like Github. The required old-school patch-by-mail thing is a blocker for a lot of people.

reply
AndrewDucker
2 hours ago
[-]
I am boggled by the number of people who see "I really don't want to X" and then reply with "Here's how to easily do X!"
reply
dethos
24 minutes ago
[-]
One of the other comments mentions https://codefloe.com. I haven't tested and haven't yet checked their background, but they seem to allow private repositories.
reply
layer8
1 hour ago
[-]
Take a look at https://www.lcube-webhosting.de/en/svn-hosting-repositoryonl..., starts at 2.90 Euro. No personal experience, but the fact that they are still including SVN support tells you how long-established they are.

Google reviews: https://www.google.com/search?q=lcube&ludocid=91685905651961...

reply
icy
20 minutes ago
[-]
https://tangled.org :) We're hosted in the EU.
reply
rapnie
3 hours ago
[-]
Regarding Forgejo [0] there are a number of other open providers listed on the delightful forgejo [1] curated list. In addition there is a Professional services repository [2] where services are listed in the issue tracker.

[0] https://forgejo.org

[1] https://delightful.coding.social/delightful-forgejo/#public-...

[2] https://codeberg.org/forgejo/professional-services/issues

reply
p2detar
3 hours ago
[-]
I self-host Forgejo on a Docker container. Thinking about it, this is actually the right way to go.

If you got public projects, then something like Codeberg is in fact the place to go. If you got private projects, why push to someone's cloud-hosted git service at all? Push to your own service like Forgejo and sync backups to a local hard-drive or even online using rclone.

reply
nottorp
2 hours ago
[-]
Because I don't mind paying github $4 or $7 and not worry about the admin burden.

Of course, this goes for simpler setups where you only use the git hosting part. Because to switch providers you only have to change the remote and push.

If you got yourself dependent on their other pipelines, it's more complicated.

reply
christophilus
2 hours ago
[-]
I think Sourcehut is EU based now.
reply
thijsw
2 hours ago
[-]
Yes, check out https://www.gitlabhost.com/ It is based in the Netherlands
reply
roelschroeven
2 hours ago
[-]
AFAICS the cheapest option is 250€/month. That seems geared towards businesses, not individuals.
reply
I_am_tiberius
2 hours ago
[-]
Crazy expensive for small projects
reply
fanatic2pope
2 hours ago
[-]
For just the basics, self-hosting of git can be pretty easy. I use gitolite on a VPS.

https://gitolite.com/gitolite/

reply
teekert
3 hours ago
[-]
Uhm, is it? I have some small repos there, which are private and for my company (ie the website). I didn't encounter any warnings?

Edit, it says indeed (right in your face on the front page):

Codeberg is a non-profit, community-led effort that provides services to free and open-source projects, such as Git hosting.

I just click... click opened a repo and set it as remote and boom. Never thought anything of it... Perhaps I'm... Tolerated for the time being?

reply
PurpleRamen
1 hour ago
[-]
You are just a glitch in their system. They won't check the content of private repos, and they probably also do not check if there is free software hosted at the same account, so you might have found the hole in their good will.

But their limit seems around 100 MB storage-usage, so I guess it's within their abilities to tolerate some glitches.

reply
teekert
49 minutes ago
[-]
Ah ok, well, save for some drafts I wouldn't mind opening the repo which is just a Hugo system intended for a public website anyway. But good to know. Perhaps I will self-host that forgejo instance then :)
reply
olavgg
3 hours ago
[-]
Gitea is one of the easiest projects to to self-host. And to do regular upgrades, you only need to update one file. It has been a joy to self-host for many years now.
reply
Jnr
2 hours ago
[-]
I don't even update one file. I run it in docker with daily automatic container updates and it has been working fine without issues for years.
reply
lynx97
3 hours ago
[-]
Git is extremely easy to "self host". What makes things complicated are the web interfaces around code hosting, and all their supposedly important features. These days, Prs, issues, forums, wikis and all that seem to be synonymous with "git", which is pretty weird.
reply
kace91
3 hours ago
[-]
What do you mean by supposedly?

The PR model is pretty much universal for a reason. I get why it is considered out of scope for core git, but it is by no means a weird fixation people have.

reply
lynx97
3 hours ago
[-]
Just send me an email with your branches URL, and I will pull from it. Thats pretty much what a Pull Request is.
reply
kace91
2 hours ago
[-]
>Thats pretty much what a Pull Request is.

Then you have to use email for the review conversation, make the discussion easily available to everyone involved and future devs, track manually which comment refers to which line of the diff due to lack of overlaying, manually ping to warn of updates, rely on manual quoting, no direct information on whether the CI pipeline succeeded...

To me that feels like writing code using only sed. It is possible, but it removes or makes convoluted an absurd degree of regular work.

reply
Jnr
2 hours ago
[-]
You are correct, but integration with CI/CD and other services as a part of pull-request process in a modern platform is very convenient. I would not go back to e-mail. Especially since I can self host the whole platform like Gitea.
reply
hvb2
3 hours ago
[-]
And the discussion about that PR goes in an email chain too?

You can pull, but having the back and forth documented along with the code is not a nice to have imho

reply
spiffyk
3 hours ago
[-]
Not that it fits everyone, but that is basically how the Linux kernel is being developed.
reply
cyanydeez
3 hours ago
[-]
Guys, guys, I'm just vibe coding here; just give me your credentials and mothers maiden name and I'll get it myself.
reply
lynx97
2 hours ago
[-]
If it is not in git log, a few months down the drain, nobody will read the PR discussion anyway.
reply
rapnie
3 hours ago
[-]
Because there isn't really a good name. In FOSS circles the name "code forge" is often used, and then OP might say "git-based code forge" instead. But both Github and Gitlab don't consider themself (and aren't) code forges. The term doesn't carry the load of the product positioning. So "hosting provider for git" is a pretty good description imho.
reply
ptsneves
3 hours ago
[-]
Which is ironic because PR is definitely alien to git. There is no such git concept as a PR, nor git pr command.

Coming from a pure git workflow in mailing lists where branches, and commits(and associated diff and git am metadata) are the unit of work, I struggled to adapt into the PR concept in the beginning.

I liked to work with gerrit, where the unit of the review is the commit. This also ensured a nice little history and curation of the change set. The commit in github is not even in the main tab of the PR. It is like it is a second thought. Even in the review, reviewing by commit is awkward and discouraged.

reply
_flux
3 hours ago
[-]
There are the commands git request-pull and git send-email to work with that workflow, though.
reply
cyanydeez
3 hours ago
[-]
gitlab ce is easy to host.
reply
sam_lowry_
3 hours ago
[-]
Here's a step-by step guide:

Change directory to your local git repository that you want to share with friends and colleagues and do a bare clone git clone --bare . /tmp/repo.git You just created a copy of the .git folder without all the checked out files.

Upload /tmp/repo.git to your linux server over ssh. Don't have one? Just order a tiny cloud server from Hetzner or another European provider. You can place your git repository anywhere, but the best way is to put it in a separate folder, e.g. /var/git. The command would look like with scp -r /tmp/repo.git me@server:/var/git/.

To share the repository with others, create a group, e.g. groupadd --users me git You will be able to add more users to the group with groupmod.

Your git repository is now writable only by me. To make it writable by the git group, you have to change the group on all files in the repository to git with chgrp -R git /var/repo.git and enable the group write bit on them with chmod -R g+w /var/repo.git.

This fixes the shared access for existing files. For new files, we have to make sure the group write bit is always on by changing UMASK from 022 to 002 in /etc/login.defs.

There is one more trick. For now on, all new files and folders in /var/git will be created with the user's primary group. We could change users to have git as the primary group.

But we can also force all new files and folders to be created with the parent folder's group and not user primary group. For that, set the group sticky bit on all folders in /var/git with find /var/git -type d -exec chmod g+s \{\} +

You are done.

Want to host your git repository online? Install caddy and point to /var/git with something like

    example.com {
      root * /var/git
      file_server
    }
Your git repository will be instantly accessible via https://example.com/repo.git.
reply
appstorelottery
3 hours ago
[-]
I would add Hetzner for hosting. German based, solid in my experience with virtual servers.
reply
aleph_minus_one
1 hour ago
[-]
In Germany, netcup (https://www.netcup.com/) is also quite popular among customers who are

- small or midsize companies, or

- "hacker-minded people" (I know quite some "hacker-minded people" who rent a server or vServer at netcup),

since they offer quite a bit of value for the money. In opposite to Hetzner, netcup is more of an inside tip.

reply
tonydav
2 hours ago
[-]
For mail I've been using migadu.

I self host most services: contacts, calendar, git, ..

Agree on mullvad, buy giftcard on amazon.

Tried hetzner, but it wouldn't allow me to create an account. Ovh it is.

I haven't thought about registrars, I don't think it matters for most tld. (Moniker, porkbun)

reply
kioleanu
2 hours ago
[-]
If you buy directly from Mullvad, they delete the transaction details after two weeks. Sure, your payment procesor knows you’ve bought from Mullvad, but in this case so does Amazon, no?

Regarding Migadu, after extensive research it seemed to be the best option, but man that 20 outgoing emails limit is just so off-putting and the next tier is so far apart. I would be comfortable paying 50-60 euros per year for 50 outgoing emails, but no, it’s either 20 for 20 euros or 100 for 90 euros

reply
aktau
2 hours ago
[-]
> Agree on mullvad, buy giftcard on amazon.

I've heard this before. Is this just to add another hop in the chain to make it harder for someone to track the user down? Apart from someone needing to order Amazon to pony up the details ("Which credit card was this Amazon item bought with?")

Is there another layer of privacy I'm missing?

reply
drcharris
37 minutes ago
[-]
The gift card is a scratch off and has a number that is used to fund your Mullvad balance. So Amazon doesn't know which instance of the gift card you ordered, meaning there's no link to your specific Mullvad account payment.

The authorities might know you ordered a gift card, but not which Mullvad account you funded it with.

reply
bombcar
2 hours ago
[-]
Giftcards from Amazon will be enough of a stumbling block to stop copyright trolls and such.

it won't even slow down actual criminal investigations by nation states and might not even stop a determined civil suit.

reply
actionfromafar
2 hours ago
[-]
Or send cash in an envelope.
reply
tonydav
2 hours ago
[-]
Doesn't cost extra

No need to share my cc with yet another company.

reply
NoSalt
45 minutes ago
[-]
> "the EU currently has the most user-friendly laws when it comes to data protection"

I have not done any research into this facet of EU laws, but isn't the EU simply horrible when it comes to privacy of your data from a nosy government?

reply
jojomodding
40 minutes ago
[-]
In what sense are governments in the EU more nosy than the one in the US or China?
reply
cl3misch
42 minutes ago
[-]
I think OP means user-friendly in the relationship user-company, not user-government.
reply
bkolobara
1 hour ago
[-]
Shameless plug. We have been working on building a European GitHub alternative for private repos at https://lubeno.dev.
reply
andix
3 hours ago
[-]
Is there a good tool to automatically (and continuously) mirror all GitHub repositories to another provider? Something with GH API integration that also catches newly created projects/repos?

Issues and PRs would be a bonus, but not a requirement in my case.

reply
patcon
3 hours ago
[-]
Haven't used it, but I've been intrigued by git-bug (stores issues in got itself) for years, to use as the issue/pr sync.

Bonus that now the issues aren't vendor locked either

https://github.com/git-bug/git-bug/blob/trunk/doc/feature-ma...

reply
hbbio
3 hours ago
[-]
Still not accepting Codeberg moral stance.

Yes, gitea (and originally gogs) are released under permissive licenses, so it's legally allowed to fork them.

But forking complete working projects with years of work, rebranding with a "good guys" attitude, and progressively erasing the name/history (mentioning a gitea fork has moved down the faq now) is not fair.

Edit: even worse, the word "fork" is not in the FAQ. It is "Comparison with Gitea" now (fork is mentioned on that page).

reply
jen729w
3 hours ago
[-]
> Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software…

https://github.com/go-gitea/gitea/blob/main/LICENSE

If you don't want your software used like that, don't choose this licence.

You can't post-hoc decide how people behave.

reply
jdiaz97
2 hours ago
[-]
open source is all fun and games until they fork you
reply
cobalt60
1 hour ago
[-]
I mean you build a base for your oss tooling. You reject a base's notion, what do you expect?
reply
looperhacks
1 hour ago
[-]
This is already a crazy take on its own, why would a fork have to describe their relation to the parent project front and center? Both the Readme and the comparison page link to the origin blog post [1] that describes the lineage clearly.

But even if there were some "ethical reason" to do this, I don't think Gitea is the right project to play up as a victim. Their homepage [2] doesn't mention that Gitea itself is a fork either. Their Readme does, but is this so much better?

[1]: https://forgejo.org/2022-12-15-hello-forgejo/ [2]: https://about.gitea.com/

reply
Aldipower
46 minutes ago
[-]
For transactional email, Lettermint is a great email broadcaster from the Netherlands. Saying this as a German means they really must be good!
reply
pelzatessa
53 minutes ago
[-]
> I’ve always been a happy Mullvad customer. For 5 euros a month, I pay a Swedish company that has proven it doesn’t log any data

How did they prove that? Is such proof even possible?

reply
crosa
48 minutes ago
[-]
Start by the fact that in their system you are just a random number that is generated at the moment you arrive in their website. They make very easy to pay without having to use any of your personal data, like Credit Card. Overall I think if a company put so much effort on that side, they simply don't have any data to log, or if they do is pretty anonymous anyway :)
reply
pelzatessa
28 minutes ago
[-]
While their account privacy policy is commendable, it isn't a proof for not collecting logs.

Even without personal details you can collect quite a lot of data - ip address that uses certain VPN account, which servers it talks to while using vpn, at what hours, at what intervals, also all the plaintext data exchanged between client and server. A lot of data that someone (who might already have your ip address mapped to your personal info, for example your ISP, or an online store where you shopped something before you turned on the VPN) would be willing to pay good money for. And companies like money.

reply
Raed667
2 hours ago
[-]
> set up catch-all addresses but also send emails from any email address I wanted

I have been frustrated with ProtonMail for this exact reason, i have a catch all but responding is a hassle where i have to manually create an address.

I wish Proton would just allow me to respond to an email from the address it was addressed to

reply
mads_quist
1 hour ago
[-]
If you need an on-call / incident management platform like PagerDuty or incident.io All Quiet offers EU based Hosting and is operated from Germany:

https://allquiet.app

reply
dwedge
1 hour ago
[-]
While it's in your bio, I feel like you should have made it more obvious that this is your company
reply
evnsio
1 hour ago
[-]
Just for completeness, both PagerDuty and incident.io offer EU hosting.
reply
canmi21
41 minutes ago
[-]
Big companies never treat your data good. It's better to store it privately :(
reply
kuon
33 minutes ago
[-]
For domains, spread them across multiple registrars.
reply
s_dev
3 hours ago
[-]
https://european-alternatives.eu/

I recommend Scaleway for cloud hosting. I recently migrated from Digital Ocean who I really loved, to Scaleway and have I have to say impressed with both dashboard interface and pricing so far.

In work we still use AWS but everything is hosted in eu-west (Ireland) in AWS EU Sovereign cloud but not sure how truly compliant this is in a CloudAct vs GDPR showdown.

I've yet to migrate from namecheap but planning on moving my domains to inwx. My MacBook Pro will be hard to replace so that will be years away. Nothing phones look cool but I would like to go with EU solutions rather than British ones. https://commerce.jolla.com/products/jolla-phone-sep-ii-2026 looks cool but some the HackerNews guys have been quite critical so I'm still considering what those next devices will be.

reply
achayala
1 hour ago
[-]
I did the same! The only problem with this is the uptime of codeberg.org, it sucks haha, but that is not a problem for me. I have not critical services there.
reply
madflo
3 hours ago
[-]
I have been a customer of OVH’s new Zimbra Starter service. It works for my personal and professional needs, CalDAV and ActiveSync are active. I do not use the web interface so no feedback on this.
reply
choo-t
3 hours ago
[-]
Does their Zimbra implementation support 2FA ?
reply
jagermo
3 hours ago
[-]
Uberspace is solid and a lot of fun to try stuff out. For domains, i would also recommend inwx.com, they have been around for ages, good prices and no-fuzz admin stuff.
reply
FinnKuhn
3 hours ago
[-]
The author mentions using them as well, but I personally would have a really hard time trusting any service run by any individual and be it just in case something happens to them.
reply
jasonvorhe
3 hours ago
[-]
It's a team of 10+ people though.
reply
shafyy
2 hours ago
[-]
I tried Uberspace for email and what bothered me that you can only set up one email domain per Asteroid. So if you have multiple domains, it gets expensive quickly... (depending on how many users per domain you have). But other than that, great company with a great ethical stance (and as far as I can tell, great technical infrastructure). I will definitely be going back to them if I need a simple VPS.
reply
dwedge
1 hour ago
[-]
> For various reasons

Because it's trending. Likely the same reason they ended up outside the EU in the first place.

I find this to be a non article. They moved from Google to Google and Apple, installed Graphene but installed the play store for a "significant number of apps", and didn't even consider self hosting email or git.

I've probably seen a dozen of these articles now, not to mention posts on LinkedIn, and it's a shame that there is almost never any real substance to them because on the surface it's an interesting thought experiment

reply
microtonal
1 hour ago
[-]
/r/BuyFromEU is a continuous enumeration of individuals posting from what US services to EU services they moved. I agree that these posts get uninteresting once you have seen a few. I would be more interested in I have used European service X for 6 months, these are the up/downsides I found, since they actually help people picking alternatives.
reply
ta9000
11 minutes ago
[-]
Frankly many in the US are over the Trump administration and I expect a massive backlash in the midterms. Do what you want of course but I think the descent of the US is slowing and there will be a return to normalcy after this admin.
reply
severino
2 hours ago
[-]
> First, I tried mailbox.org, which I can generally recommend without reservation. Unfortunately, you can’t send emails from any address on your own domain without a workaround, so the search continued.

I had read about other problems about this mailbox.org service, but not this one. Anyone knows what's the catch when trying to send emails from your own domain?

reply
kioleanu
2 hours ago
[-]
I think he means that he can have a catch-all, but to reply from that address, there needs to be an alias created on the account
reply
brandrick
3 hours ago
[-]
Proton ticks a few of those boxes for me. Mail, VPN, Cal.
reply
robertlagrant
3 hours ago
[-]
Also docs collaboration, and now video calling as well. And they've just bought Standard Notes, so that'll be next. It's definitely chugging along fast.
reply
sime2009
2 hours ago
[-]
proton.me? That is in Switzerland, not the EU.
reply
knorker
1 hour ago
[-]
The stated reason in the article seems like Switzerland should be as good as EU, if not better.

> I have decided to move as many services and subscriptions as possible from non-EU countries to the EU or to switch to European service providers. The reasons for this are the current global political situation and improved data protection.

"or switch to European service providers". EU or not, CH is still in Europe, so would qualify?

reply
gib444
17 minutes ago
[-]
There are reasons other than privacy to move to non-US companies: e.g. not wanting contribute to the US economy and the further expansion of US tech companies. This is my main motivation in fact.

So criticisms about these kind of posts and initiatives along the lines of "EU privacy bad too" are insufficient and are unpersuasive.

reply
twoquestions
1 hour ago
[-]
For the longest time it was an economic axiom that regulations drive off businesses, and here stronger laws are directly attracting business!
reply
varjag
1 hour ago
[-]
It's the rule of law that attracts business.
reply
nopakos
1 hour ago
[-]
One concern is that if an EU company becomes very successful, it could easily be acquired by a large U.S. corporation.
reply
mafuy
11 minutes ago
[-]
If you have a good path and a bad path that may or may not converge sometime later on your journey, you still should walk the good path.
reply
gib444
15 minutes ago
[-]
You're not wrong. But no SaaS is forever. Price rises, bankruptcies, ToS changes, change of CEO etc. Being acquired by a US company is just one of the things that can happen.

For someone like the author, it's not a reason to stay with a US company

And helping European companies be more successful might prevent them from selling out...

reply
Invictus0
30 minutes ago
[-]
Don't worry, EU companies never become that successful
reply
gib444
16 minutes ago
[-]
Weird, I've worked for multiple that got acquired by US companies
reply
sobiolite
3 hours ago
[-]
I’m not with I could ever migrate away from Gmail, even if I wanted to. I have so many accounts and services linked to it.
reply
microtonal
3 hours ago
[-]
Don't make the same mistake again, get a domain so that you can keep using the same address when switching between providers. Then set up GMail to forward e-mail to your new address. Then slowly update the E-mail address in your account. You could even set up a label that gets attached to e-mails that arrived through your GMail address. In that way, you can easily see the stuff that still needs to be updated.

Untangling yourself from Google (or Apple, which is similarly hard), doesn't have to be all at once. Break it up in small steps that feel like individual wins.

One more note about using your own domain: avoid provider-specifict features like subdomain addressing (made it more work for me to move off Fastmail).

reply
vertnerd
3 hours ago
[-]
If you are using a password manager, start by searching for every record with your gmail address. Make a list. Every day, go to the next entry on the list and change your email with that app or service.

Of course, set up gmail to forward messages to your new address and filter them into a folder. Once you have changed all the services you know about, watch for emails coming to the gmail folder, looking for more services that need to be updated. Eventually the only thing arriving in the folder is spam and you can just route it all into the garbage.

reply
threethirtytwo
2 hours ago
[-]
There's no point in switching. Most of these people are dealing with a threat that has an extremely low probability of happening. It is not in any practical way going to affect your life and for most of the people here busy switching to EU services they likely don't have any major example of where it has affect them or anyone one degree away from them.

It's mostly an ideal. Like OSS. The practical reality means that such extreme adherence to only EU services doesn't do anything but make your life harder. It's like saying you only use open source, from the CPU to the GPU to your OS and everything else... make it all from open source, how big of a nightmare would that be? The only time it is practical is if you're doing really illegal shit and you need the data protection.

reply
jobigoud
1 hour ago
[-]
> doesn't do anything but make your life harder.

No it also encourages the local market and healthy competition. This way in the future we don't fall into the same enshittification trap.

reply
thejohnconway
1 hour ago
[-]
Honestly, the instability of the political environment in US feels so extreme, that it seems like something could bite you that you didn't even see coming.

Just on the Gmail front: maybe Trump decides to trade embargo you country and pressures Google to cut off email access. Maybe he decides Google needs to be broken up and sold for parts, and Gmail's data goes to Truth Social. Maybe he thinks illegal immigrants or "radical left wing lunatics" shouldn't have access to American email providers and gets Google to start suspending accounts based on a some criteria. Maybe some of this seems far fetched, but we are talking about a president who threatened to to go to war with one of America's closest allies.

The non-American west's exposure to the instability is too high, and already affecting people. Switching software providers where possible is something that can be done quickly, and relatively easily by individuals in the short term.

reply
sodapopcan
49 minutes ago
[-]
I did it with tons of accounts and services linked. It's not anywhere as daunting as you'd think (and I thought). Although it seems you don't want to move away from it so I'm not sure what point your comment serves to make.
reply
ralferoo
3 hours ago
[-]
Nowadays, I primarily only use gmail because the mail client is good on Android. But all my accounts have been self-hosted for years now and gmail just reads them via POP3 (never managed to get it happy with IMAP for some reason) and sends via my own SMTP.

Can anyone recommend actually decent and free Android (and also web) mail clients for self-hosted use? Everything I've tried so far (but to be fair, it was a few years ago when I last checked) just felt clunky compared to gmail, so I've ended up sticking with it as a client far longer than I probably should.

reply
mhitza
3 hours ago
[-]
Took me a year of slow migration so that my essential emails and connected services don't go over Gmail. Email is the hardest to move because of its central nature as an online identity.
reply
sylens
3 hours ago
[-]
It’s easier than you think when you stop trying to treat it as an all or nothing move and more of a gradual migration. Fastmail makes it really easy to keep the two in sync
reply
fsflover
3 hours ago
[-]
Set up the redirect and change the emails of your services one by one whenever you have a minute of time. It took a year for me, and I am free now.
reply
iso1631
2 hours ago
[-]
I let my old 4 letter .com domain expire around 2000ish and got suckered into the whole gmail etc thing after sitting on university and hotmail for a while

In 2019 I decided enough was enough and registered a new domain and started moving my accounts over as new ones came up, or I updated addressing

I have very little left on gmail now other than spam from old services I no longer use. Top one in the inbox at the moment is Facebook telling my I have "530 notifications about X". Its sad how desperate they are.

reply
fmajid
1 hour ago
[-]
The EU is not a privacy and human rights panacea, as shown by the continuing efforts to impose Chat Control. Switzerland is no better.

Then again one of my wife’s friends is high up in the Canadian policy establishment and some of her positions on surveillance and political control over social media were chilling, and I assume widespread among the Five Eyes. Certainly the UK and Australia have deeply authoritarian policies far beyond even Trump’s wildest dreams.

Small countries like Iceland have enlightened policies but are vulnerable to coercion and in fact were militarily occupied during WW2.

reply
max_
38 minutes ago
[-]
> The reasons for this are the current global political situation and improved data protection

I don't understand why people keep saying this when Europe is more hostile towards privacy.

The constantly insist on schemes like chat control, and GrapheneOS users are often confronted by legal authorities.

They may have "the laws", but its way less trust worthy.

reply
mafuy
13 minutes ago
[-]
You misunderstand this. Yes, there have been moves by some in the EU to reduce privacy, but they face resistance and have actually been repelled often. The ChatControl debacle you mention is one such instance. And on the other hand, sometimes there is actual progress, like with GDPR.

But more importantly, at least there are privacy laws in the EU that do something. In the US, there are virtually none, so of course you won't hear about their erosion.

I trust the EU ten times more than the US in this regard.

reply
lvales
2 hours ago
[-]
This is something I've been trying to help people and companies with excipio (shameless plug). Data and digital sovereignty are fundamental nowadays.
reply
gib444
26 minutes ago
[-]
Not a fan of Mailbox.org. It's Nextcloud for starters. The UX is clunky. They feel a 30 day web app session expiry is perfectly fine.

I've gone back to FastMail for the time being

I think what I really want is:

- FastMail or similar for sending, and receiving new emails

- An email archive system that syncs from my main email provider, deleting from the remote anything over eg 4 weeks old

I like hosted providers for their IP reputation, spam systems, deliverability etc (and in the case of FM, the excellent web UI) but I don't like them having 15 years of my email which they can read whenever they wish. (edit: yes, I realise they could just keep copies)

Does anyone else have this kind of set up? Any recommendations to remove the pain of having a mailbox split into 2?

reply
kouunji
2 hours ago
[-]
Honestly this is part of a macro trend of everyone outside the US scrambling to get off a US tech stack…these are going to be the longer term economic consequences for the country, as it is no longer seen as a safe option for any kind of data or service exposure.
reply
Invictus0
31 minutes ago
[-]
Foolish blunder
reply
u8080
1 hour ago
[-]
Reminder: Hetzner/Linode were MITMing their client(jabber.ru) withour any legal basis and past prosecution: https://notes.valdikss.org.ru/jabber.ru-mitm/
reply
_joel
3 hours ago
[-]
You can take fastmail from my cold, dead hands :D About the only thing I can rely on to actually work.
reply
shafyy
2 hours ago
[-]
Yes, same here. I tried some EU providers like Mailbox, Tuta and Uberspace. In the end, even though Fastmail is not EU-based, at least it's based in Australia (and not US) and they have a solid track record as a company to make the right decisions and not chase every hype. So, this is good enough for me. For now.
reply
evan_a_a
2 hours ago
[-]
Australia is a member of five eyes and the US basically treats them like the 51st state.
reply
creantum
1 hour ago
[-]
Out of the pan into the fire
reply
pennaMan
2 hours ago
[-]
> the EU currently has the most user-friendly laws when it comes to data protection

This is laughable. The EU has the most big-tech regulatory capture friendly data laws that make it really hard for small companies to compete, nicely packaged under consumer protection pretenses.

Those same laws give the institutions of the state complete and total right to silently wiretap the digital existence of anyone, at any time, for any reason.

reply
piokoch
2 hours ago
[-]
I wonder what will happen when Jordan Bardella will be new France president and Alice Weidel will be German Chancellor. Where people are going to migrate to then...
reply
silexia
1 hour ago
[-]
The EU has far worse freedom of speech laws than the US, most websites would be insane to migrate to the EU.
reply
atoav
3 hours ago
[-]
One tip in the EU is to consider just renting a Hetzner Storage Share. This is a 1TB (or more) Nextcloud that Hetzner manages for you for 5.11 Euros per month.

A Nextcloud can give you many things at once, file syncing, file shares, contact syncing, calendar syncing, etc.

I have been using this for years now after having hosted my own Nextcloud instance. The space and performance they give you for that price is unbeatable with nearly no downsides. The one downside is that you can't just ssh into the server, but you can even run occ managment commands via their web interface. It is an absolute no-brainer.

reply
majoe
2 hours ago
[-]
Had a self hosted nextcloud instance runnning on my homeserver, but migrated away two years ago to a Hetzner Storage share. All in all I'm quite happy with that.

There are some downsides, though:

  - No support for collabora online, so no way for collaborative editing of office files
  - Data is not encrypted

Hetzner also has classical web hosting offerings, which are cheap as well. I'm using that for email and a website of mine.
reply
gib444
13 minutes ago
[-]
I've just rented one a few days ago!

It's not a full-on Nextcloud instance, mind. For example there is no ffmpeg for generating video thumbnails.

But liking it so far

reply
robertlagrant
3 hours ago
[-]
I had no idea how cheap this was. Thanks.
reply
ankit7000
2 hours ago
[-]
"Running a €5 Hetzner VPS in Helsinki for 1+ year — CPX22 gives 3vCPU 4GB RAM. For most indie devs the EU infra is genuinely better value than US providers at the same price point."
reply
BoredPositron
3 hours ago
[-]
Blast from the past... I really miss fluxbox but I also need Wayland because of different refresh rate monitors and the last time I checked waybox wasn't there yet.
reply
dipshady
1 hour ago
[-]
hello
reply
sph
3 hours ago
[-]
I'm also pretty much using 100% EU services except FastMail. Nothing against the Aussies, but I'd rather use something local, with servers within the EU.

But I don't think there's anything as good as Fastmail this side of the pond, and I'm not prepared to compromise on this just yet. I might self-host email despite all the dangers the day FM decides to enshittify itself.

reply
heinrich5991
3 hours ago
[-]
I've used https://migadu.com/ before. Not EU, but EEA (Switzerland).
reply
ktta
3 hours ago
[-]
ProtonMail? Not strictly speaking EU, but atleast EEA

It also comes with a whole suite of software that you don't have to find EU alternatives for like Calendar, Drive, Password manager, etc

reply
sph
3 hours ago
[-]
I like privacy, but a service that's focused on maximum possible privacy for its users paints a target on its back for any three-letter agency, as it will attract a large contingent of unsavoury people.
reply
mvdwoord
3 hours ago
[-]
I just onboarded and was dumbfounded that they do not allow for proper calendar exposure other than a fully public link! The claim of zero knowledge is super cute, for those that need it, but I need a provider which allows me to integrate the calendar elsewhere, as those will not magically move into Proton. I guess I am not in their target market.
reply
antics9
3 hours ago
[-]
https://tuta.com/ and Protonmail
reply
perakojotgenije
3 hours ago
[-]
https://mailbox.org/

German e-mail service

reply
NoboruWataya
3 hours ago
[-]
Seconding this - reasonable pricing and I haven't had any issues at all with the service. I haven't used FastMail but most things I read suggest they are very similar in terms of what they offer so I would think Mailbox is a good EU alternative for someone who likes FastMail. (There are also other EU providers like Tuta but with slightly different trade-offs, ie, more emphasis on privacy but at the expense of IMAP/SMTP support.)
reply
eigenspace
2 hours ago
[-]
I switched to mailbox recently and I'm finding it quite good. I set it up with a custom domain, and that did require a bit of fuzting around, but the friction there was almost all on the side of my VPS hosting service, not Mailbox's fault.
reply
evan_a_a
2 hours ago
[-]
I'm using Startmail, based in NL: https://www.startmail.com
reply
ongy
3 hours ago
[-]
I love fastmail, but I really wish they had servers close to me.

The high ping kills the throughput on davfs and makes their website hosting a pain to update :(

reply
josephg
3 hours ago
[-]
Where abouts are you located?
reply
yellowsir
3 hours ago
[-]
reply
sylware
2 hours ago
[-]
Slight detail: EU does not know how to design performant mobile/server/desktop CPUs (and GPUs). But they have ASML and "obsolete" foundries.
reply
chupasaurus
1 hour ago
[-]
Yeah, and ARM is based outside of EU, just across La Manche and Irish Sea.
reply
sylware
39 minutes ago
[-]
One: ARM has been softbank for a good while now. And softband is japanese. Two: ARM ISA is heavily IP locked.

For the moment, would be much more appropriate to design performant implementations (mobile/server/desktop) on RISC-V ISA.

reply
jdiaz97
2 hours ago
[-]
yeah the blog is about software, not hardware
reply
sylware
42 minutes ago
[-]
software runs on hardware.
reply
chairhairair
2 hours ago
[-]
"This way, I can enjoy YouTube ad-free and without an account."

Not having the gumption to actually give it up. Pathetic.

reply
retinaros
2 hours ago
[-]
migrating to a re gion that votes laws to restrict freedom of speech, wants to remove anonymity from social network and can block your bank account for opinions that do not align with european stance on things like for instance mass migrations from third world countries. Yeah seems a smart move.
reply
debugnik
3 hours ago
[-]
And yet the hardware had to stay all American brands, how sad we barely compete there.
reply
dude250711
3 hours ago
[-]
That ship had sailed long ago.
reply
drstewart
2 hours ago
[-]
Another daily thread on this topic. Interesting. What makes this one unique and not exactly like every other one?
reply
lynx97
3 hours ago
[-]
I find it pretty ironical that people seem to want to move to Von der Leyens vision of the future. As a EU citizen, my trust in what recently has been going down is almost non-existant.
reply
ludvigk
3 hours ago
[-]
I guess when the alternative is Trump's vision of the future ... - at least I know what I would choose.
reply
CalRobert
3 hours ago
[-]
I agree, and moved to the EU from the US for related reasons, but Von der Leyen's entire strategy for handling Trump seems to be immediate capitulation to horrendously one-sided deals, which doesn't give a lot of confidence.
reply
mytailorisrich
3 hours ago
[-]
Trump will be gone in 2028 and policies may radically change depending on who replaces him. There is no change on the horizon in the EU when Von Der Leyen is replaced (she is just the current public face of the blob...)
reply
konradx
2 hours ago
[-]
Do you believe this ? Even if the Americans get out of their zombie existence and get out to vote (on another candidate), I cannot imagine Trump will accept an election loss. (A reminder: The US has had a 24% drop in the Liberal Democracy Index score in just one year and your supreme court is owned)
reply
nslsm
2 hours ago
[-]
Von der Leyen has made it clear the values of the EU are exactly the same as those of the US: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zEbQoT3Xlho
reply
s_dev
56 minutes ago
[-]
That video is from 11 months ago, long before Trump was elected for his second term. Once was an anomaly. Twice is nearly a pattern but not an anomaly. Third time is an established pattern.
reply
aborsy
2 hours ago
[-]
Some of these European countries such as France are quite authoritarian. They frequently pass (update: propose/push for) laws to ban VPN and even social media, request access to private messages, etc. It seems to me the situation is equally bad in EU.
reply
9dev
2 hours ago
[-]
You have no idea what you are talking about, really. We don’t "frequently" pass such laws. Nobody is accessing private messages, even if there have been such attempts.

The EU has still the strongest privacy laws world wide, and in contrast to others a strong ethical foundation. It may be slow, it may be torn, it may be overly beaurocratic, but sure enough not authoritarian.

reply
mytailorisrich
49 minutes ago
[-]
France is routinely criticised for its police, justice system, and rule of law. In general only the French believe that they are a shining beacon. [1]

[1] https://worldjusticeproject.org/rule-of-law-index/country/Fr...

reply
prmoustache
22 minutes ago
[-]
I don't think the french as a whole believe that. A lot of people in France are highly critical of the way the current government (and how it is more and more far right leaning) has been handling things in the last decade. There is a big issue of the police forces syndicates being highly far right biased which doesn't help.

Like many countries, it is not homogeneous.

reply
antievropean
1 hour ago
[-]
Two words: chat control
reply
prmoustache
25 minutes ago
[-]
reply
Aldipower
51 minutes ago
[-]
Defeated! (At least for now...)
reply
gradus_ad
2 hours ago
[-]
The EU is going to fail in the next decade or two. It is a financially and politically unsustainable patchwork that will rip apart in the great power conflict that is coming. The sick man of Europe is now Europe itself.
reply
alexejb
2 hours ago
[-]
Assuming your assessment is correct, how do you think this will affect the digital sector?
reply
gradus_ad
1 hour ago
[-]
Capital flows to where it enjoys the greatest returns. That is not Europe, not now nor in any foreseeable future. There is no reason for a skilled professional interested in making money to go there.
reply
alexejb
36 minutes ago
[-]
I don't think that this was the intention of the original blog post. It's about _digital_ migration for tech savvy folks who want to decouple from us-based tech monopolists.
reply
Aldipower
48 minutes ago
[-]
You know, making money is not everything. Why should I be rich in a third-world country (the US).
reply