Tell HN: Reddit now demands to know why you won't use their app
11 points
4 hours ago
| 9 comments
| HN
When you try to dismiss Reddit's mobile web prompt asking you to switch to their app, instead of just going away, it now gets replaced with this poll:

> What is the primary reason you don't want to download the Reddit app?

> I want to save space on my device

> I don't use Reddit often enough

> I prefer the privacy of my web browser

> I want to avoid push notifications

> I already have the Reddit app

> I get what I need from the web browser

Bender
3 hours ago
[-]
[x] I do not install apps for anyone for any reason. I browse from Firefox on Linux on mini-PC's and laptops without exception.

Why won't they install my curl | bash cron job that runs as root on all their servers? I pinky-promise it's mostly harmless.

reply
Terr_
4 hours ago
[-]
[x] "Everything you've been making is so user-hostile and unhelpful to my needs that when you remove old.reddit.com I will block Reddit links from my search results entirely."

_______________

P.S.: As a hardcore Reddit commenter for over a decade who remembers moving from Digg, I'm mostly-serious. When there's an actual human discussion, I do not want to squint at a tiny viewable area, evading ads-that-look-like-comments, and manually iterating through dozens of "load more that are hidden" link-buttons... some of which will cause a page transition and completely reset all progress.

This is especially true when I'm trying to find some crucial keyword (perhaps one a search-engine told me exists) but I can't just ctrl-f the through comments anymore.

No, at that point... Well, at that point I will turn to something that would otherwise be anathema, a malevolent "solution" so horrible that it shows just how bad the problem is... I will seek a summary from [ominous thunderclap] an LLM!

reply
al_borland
1 hour ago
[-]
This sounds like an admission that the app can and will violate user privacy more so than the browser.
reply
youniverse
1 hour ago
[-]
I'd wager it's more just more addiction/engagement since people/kids probably develop a deeper habit scrolling on a phone instead of a bigger screen.
reply
BLKNSLVR
2 hours ago
[-]
The last option is a trick. If enough people select it, Reddit will cease to be usable (or just further decrease its usability?) via web browser.
reply
pogue
2 hours ago
[-]
Can you block it as an element in Brave browser or prevent scripts from running or anything?
reply
nkreats
2 hours ago
[-]
Pain in the butt if you ask me. They are trying to make it really annoying to use the web based reddit lol.
reply
k310
3 hours ago
[-]
I get daily requests to answer polls.

Like my time is worth zero. Is theirs?

Delete.

reply
kazinator
3 hours ago
[-]
Basically they just need one more option:

> You'll never get me to use the app so stop trying.

I mean for the sake of the completeness of their how-to-get-people-to-use-app research, not just the benefit of the user who doesn't want the app.

You will not convert 100% of people to the app, unless you shut down the website, or make it so unusable on mobile that it might as well be shut down.

reply
OccamsMirror
2 hours ago
[-]
If they shut down the website and the decent third party apps, I'd actually stop browsing Reddit.

That sounds like a net positive, to be honest.

reply
ares623
4 hours ago
[-]
Lol. Lmao even. They know why, so why bother with a poll? Is someone trying to get justification for nerfing the browser experience more? I suspect the last item will be the most popular option. Who the hell thinks "I want to save space on my device".
reply