EU Age Control: The trojan horse for digital IDs
64 points
2 hours ago
| 7 comments
| juraj.bednar.io
| HN
https://web.archive.org/web/20260426040218/https://juraj.bed...
mayama
44 minutes ago
[-]
With the way elections changed after social media became big. Govts want to have control back, like they did before. And are increasingly curbing open internet and AI wave made it worse. Ultimately we'll get 2nd hand version of great firewall and social credit system. Some liberal democracies already have root of such systems implemented.
reply
delusional
20 minutes ago
[-]
I don't know if it has anything to do with changes in elections directly. My government has been talking for a while making the case that social media use makes us dumber, sadder, and more scared. I believe it's true that they also see that playing out in elections, but that's not where they want to solve a problem.

Wouldn't it be strange if solving a problem didn't affect elections?

reply
coldtea
12 minutes ago
[-]
>My government has been talking for a while making the case that social media use makes us dumber, sadder, and more scared. I believe it's true that they also see that playing out in elections, but that's not where they want to solve a problem.

The governments themselves are "dumber, sadder, and more scared". They are worried because social media puts regular people talking on equal footing to official propagandas (being able to reach everybody else). That's what they fear, because they have the lowest approval ratings and legitimization in over half a century, and they're also making everything shittier and shittier to the benefit of their corporate overlords.

reply
CalRobert
4 minutes ago
[-]
It could be both
reply
coppsilgold
22 minutes ago
[-]
It seems unlikely that a true Zero Knowledge Proof system for things like age verification would ever be allowed.

Also, remote attestation doesn't work that way and for good reason. Under a true ZKP system, a single defector (extracted/leaked/etc key) would be able to generate an infinite number of false attestations without detection.

reply
wolvoleo
1 hour ago
[-]
> In any case, it was always presented as a toolbox that countries should adapt into their apps – so judging the app by itself does not make much sense, it depends on how these techniques are implemented in each country’s verification app. There will be no single EU app, despite what the honchos of EU say.

Even more reason to make the "demo" app do things correctly because it's very unlikely that all member states actually implement things correctly.

> The internet is scary, parents think they can’t protect their children from many bad things happening, and someone came to provide a “solution."

A simple solution is just not providing your kids with a phone or computer.

Don't forget that many sources of porn will not obey this. Think the pirate bay will ask for age verification? If they obeyed the law they wouldn't even exist.

It's a solution for nothing, as the article points out too.

reply
6r17
48 minutes ago
[-]
Whether there is a single app or not doesn't really matter - i'm more concerned about the database itself and the inter-connectivity between them and most importantly by which control acceptance protocol we abide between states.

The idea that we want a single database or a network without any kind of control is frightening me

reply
delusional
25 minutes ago
[-]
What do you mean by "control" here? It's my understanding that EU law afford citizens the right to correct data that is wrong about them.
reply
choo-t
1 minute ago
[-]
The problem is not about the data being correct or not, it's about its existence in the first place.

Why would you correct data about you very own surveillance ?

reply
narennayagam
20 minutes ago
[-]
Interesting point about ZKP systems. The challenge with age verification is balancing privacy with enforcement — any centralized solution creates a honeypot for data breaches.
reply
dmitrygr
1 hour ago
[-]
reply
kimi
1 minute ago
[-]
Archive returns 503 ATM....
reply
dang
1 hour ago
[-]
Thanks, we'll put that in the toptext too.
reply
coumbaya
52 minutes ago
[-]
ai;dr
reply
wolvoleo
1 hour ago
[-]
Site seems slashdotted? Or HNd? Do we call it that here? :)
reply
QuantumNomad_
1 hour ago
[-]
Some call it the HN hug of death. Same like with Reddit.
reply