New research suggests people can communicate and practice skills while dreaming
123 points
3 hours ago
| 25 comments
| newyorker.com
| HN
https://archive.ph/6wKhx
ml_basics
57 minutes ago
[-]
During my time at university studying pure mathematics I had an interesting experience of doing a challenging sheet of combinatorics problems during a vacation. Every day I attempted one question and got stuck on it. Then the next morning I woke up knowing the solution. It was a recurring thing: this happened every day for about 2 weeks until I had solved all the problems.

For me this a big eye opener about the importance of sleep and relaxed thinking to solve challenging problems.

reply
renegade-otter
52 minutes ago
[-]
Yeah, when you are stuck, put away that red bull and step away from the keyboard, kids.
reply
pants2
50 minutes ago
[-]
This might be why agentic development/vibe coding leads to more burn out. It's been a long time since I've truly been 'stuck' on a problem and needed to sleep on it to figure out the answer. Now I just ask Claude to fix it until it's fixed...
reply
krashidov
18 minutes ago
[-]
FWIW I've had the opposite experience. Whenever I work late the output is absolute garbage. If I work past midnight it takes me 3 hours to get done what would have taken me 30 mins in the morning, and with way less frustration and stress. Your inputs to the LLM are only as good as how fresh your mind is so I've made it a rule to not work past midnight (unless there's an emergency).

In the good old days you would reach flow and actually know when you're too tired to continue. Now you can just say "please just fix it" over and over again and get yourself in a slophole much easier.

reply
malux85
32 minutes ago
[-]
Then you're not challenging yourself with hard enough problems (those include the set of problems Claude cannot solve)
reply
pants2
23 minutes ago
[-]
Most software doesn't really have "hard enough problems" unless you're working in deep tech. The majority of SWEs are probably working on some sort of SaaS which isn't super challenging for a model like Opus 4.7. Most of the problems I face are on the product side, which I do need to take time to think through, but it's not as challenging as debugging in the good old days.
reply
Toutouxc
56 seconds ago
[-]
How do you go from SaaS to “not super challenging”? The part of a SaaS product that I’m working on uses graph algorithms to work with what’s essentially an interactive form. There’s some mildly university-level computer science stuff and it’s mixed with enough domain expertise that Opus 4.7 is still unable to make even small changes without breaking everything or going against the architecture.

So far I’m not that impressed.

reply
nick_
34 minutes ago
[-]
AFAIK this is called sleep consolidation.
reply
vanviegen
8 minutes ago
[-]
I once solved a particularly nasty bug, causing a c++ server to segfault in production about once a week, in a dream! The eureka adrenaline woke me up, and I rushed to my laptop to find the insight was real. I had been trying to comprehend that segfault for several long days. It wasn't the most restful night though.
reply
franze
1 minute ago
[-]
yeah i hate it when i work while sleeping

Me: "I'm gonna plan the workshop tomorrow, more than enough time."

7,5 h Later

Brain: "Hey, here is everything, worked the whole night, no need to thank me!!!"

Me: "I need coffee..."

reply
throwforfeds
7 minutes ago
[-]
There's a long history of doing yogic practice in the dream state: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dream_yoga
reply
matthewfcarlson
33 minutes ago
[-]
I read a short novel about a technology that allowed you to have a VR like experience while dreaming. Of course, there was all the fun/perverted stuff you can think of but also it was immediately put to use as a corporate tool. Over a few years, more and more white collar jobs shifted to night shifts where you worked via dream VR. Then people were available during the day to do whatever, watch their kids, pursue hobbies, etc. In many ways- it was a very promising future.
reply
Xeoncross
1 hour ago
[-]
AI does the work during the day and we learn while sleeping. Society doesn't collapse from ignorance. We have a new movie plot gentlemen.
reply
chaqchase
9 minutes ago
[-]
Sounds like mental rehearsal more than magic. Interesting, but I'm not sure what to do differently day to day.
reply
rcarmo
58 minutes ago
[-]
So I guess having dreams about recurring meetings is... honing corporate skills?
reply
saltcured
51 minutes ago
[-]
Is the main theme that you suddenly realize you aren't wearing pants?

And if so, would you say it has improved your pants wearing performance on the job?

reply
suprjami
54 minutes ago
[-]
It also counts as overtime, right?
reply
dgb23
44 minutes ago
[-]
Aside, but I struggled a long time with regular sleep. I have been a night owl since I was a kid. I experience late hours as magical, don’t know how to describe it. So I always slept too little, then not at all, then drifting and sleeping in.

But I somehow managed to have a regular schedule and now I start to sleep at 00:00-01:00 very often, sometimes even earlier.

No idea how I managed to do that. I guess I just did improve many small things, like getting rid of bad habits, being more content, appreciating sleep more, prioritizing things differently.

I wish everyone good, healthy sleep.

reply
thenthenthen
1 hour ago
[-]
Two months ago my partner recorded me speaking in my sleep. I was speaking fluent Mandarin. I always thought sleep time is used for learning (among healing etc), but now I am convinced.
reply
detribaby
1 hour ago
[-]
Well you’ll have to give us more. Do you speak Mandarin at all?
reply
tsukurimashou
52 minutes ago
[-]
spoiler, he is Chinese and only speaks Mandarin
reply
consumer451
1 hour ago
[-]
And, what was the partner's ability to benchmark? What is their level of familiarity with the language?

I would love to believe.

reply
jtbayly
55 minutes ago
[-]
It was a recording. I dare you to ask for it.
reply
ghm2180
33 minutes ago
[-]
The newyorker has fascinating and well written medical stories. For example, Dhruv Khullar always writes amazing columns https://www.newyorker.com/contributors/dhruv-khullar
reply
praveen4463
28 minutes ago
[-]
I feel walking outside and thinking is a better way to practice skills and solve problems. A tired mind just sleeps and usually doesn't remember current events.
reply
samtheDamned
35 minutes ago
[-]
reply
jesse_dot_id
1 hour ago
[-]
Lucid dreaming is a cool concept but I've never been able to pull it off. I still try, though!
reply
JumpCrisscross
1 hour ago
[-]
It sort of just happened to me a few years ago. It’s neat—flying is fun. (As is the opposite, when it just doesn’t work and I wake up sort of laughing at myself for having spent, presumably, hours jumping around in my dream.)

But at least for me, the price was dreams, the moment I go lucid, ceasing to be self directed. I get that I’m in a movie, and I have to always create the next step. Nothing surprises or horrifies anymore. (If I’m lucid.) I have to kind of create my own magic, which isn’t particularly restful.

reply
karmakurtisaani
1 hour ago
[-]
Yep, same. The dream gets incredibly boring after you get control of it.
reply
kbrkbr
28 minutes ago
[-]
Not if you are an aphantast.
reply
chrz
50 minutes ago
[-]
but but, you can do whatever you want?
reply
bnreed
31 minutes ago
[-]
I've had limited experience (n~20) but no... that's not how it worked for me, interested in others' experiences.

"flying" was limited. I didn't have full control and sometimes felt dynamically pinned to the top of a 2D scrolling video game as if there were driver incompatabilities.

drifting off to sleep in a session, it was very disturbing- i felt like i was being dragged by my ankle across the bed before lucid dreaming began, "here it comes..."

Sometimes there would be ominious sounds/visuals that I could not influence that scared me so much I was glad I could wake up because it felt like a nightmare was approaching.

Two big tells I'm lucid dreaming: I'm with a group of people who can't answer a very obvious question ("why is the sky blue?") or, I look at my hand - as if it were LLM it absolutely does not render well... like a tree trunk with a bunch of branches.

reply
satvikpendem
1 hour ago
[-]
Keep a dream journal. There any many methods for achieving it but if you keep a dream journal long enough you'll start getting consistent lucid dreams.
reply
zeta0134
1 hour ago
[-]
My tell is to recognize any room with a piano in it. I naturally want to sit down and play this piano, but the keys are totally wrong. No problem, I'll look around and, lo and behold, dozens more pianos all... with the keys in the wrong places. I can't play anything. "Oh, this again. I must be dreaming. How frustrating."
reply
microtonal
56 minutes ago
[-]
A very regularly occuring dream is that I'm in a train and realize that I don't have a ticket (never happened IRL), so I want to buy an e-ticket, but the ticketing app does not work. The text changes all the time, the buttons move around, weird errors, and then I realize 'yep I'm in a dream again'.

The nicer lucid dreams are those were you can fly or make spectacular light and colors, but I find that it's usually a difficult balance to avoid waking up.

reply
magiclaw
1 hour ago
[-]
I was really into it in my early 20's. One way to tell if you are mentally in the state to lucid dream is if you no longer feel tired. One night, after a grueling hike, I was completely exhausted when I went to bed. I closed my eyes, and moments later all my exhaustion just vanished, and I began to explore the space.
reply
galleywest200
1 hour ago
[-]
Another way is to try to see what the clock faces say in your dream. Also, see if the light switches behave as you would expect.
reply
typeish
33 minutes ago
[-]
there's a wearable dropping this year that's supposed to make it easier to lucid dream: https://www.prophetic.com/
reply
bryanrasmussen
1 hour ago
[-]
reply
nomel
1 hour ago
[-]
Edison, famously, solved problems in a light dream state [1].

[1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/thomas-edisons-na...

reply
petra
1 hour ago
[-]
Have anybody managed to use sleep to learn language? How ?
reply
neom
44 minutes ago
[-]
I have dyslexia and in high school learning my lines for plays was really hard but I loved doing plays, so I recorded myself saying my lines on tape (yah, I'm old) and used double cassette to fill 2 tapes with them, then run them over night while I was sleeping. I've never used this in my adult life but it worked pretty well for my lines and I suppose maybe you could use it to learn a language?

Edit: Claude tells me I was a head of my time, apparently it works but not net new, you have to also be working on it awake, it's called 'targeted memory reactivation (TMR)": https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12592824/

reply
spudlyo
50 minutes ago
[-]
While I think it's a compelling idea that playing speech in your target language while you sleep can help, I don't think it's ever been demonstrated to work.

Having said that, that sleep is incredibly important for learning anything! I practice my language learning during the day, a little bit every day, and I prioritize getting good sleep. This is mostly just trying to go to bed at the same time every night, avoiding alcohol, and giving myself an hour before bed with low lights to read and calm my mind. When you sleep, memories are consolidated, organized, and tagged for long-term storage. I will sometimes wake up in the middle of the night and bouncing around in my mind are echos of phrases and words from my target language. I figure it's working.

reply
Cthulhu_
37 minutes ago
[-]
Dexter, from Dexter's Lab, learned French.
reply
CrzyLngPwd
1 hour ago
[-]
reply
Argonaut998
52 minutes ago
[-]
Interestingly this is not something native to Tibetan Buddhists. Neoplatonists had something similar, and even Orthodox Christian monks speak about literally "praying ceaselessly" which inludes prayer during sleep, it's definitely all lucid dreaming
reply
hughw
49 minutes ago
[-]
While you're sleeping I'm practicing my skills. Enjoy being poor, suckers!
reply
matthewfcarlson
32 minutes ago
[-]
While you were sleeping, I was practicing the art of the blade
reply
andai
1 hour ago
[-]
> In perhaps the most striking example of learning during sleep, Konkoly, Paller, and several collaborators witnessed what amounted to conversations with people who were in the midst of dreams. Independent lab groups in the U.S., France, Germany, and the Netherlands asked lucid dreamers to answer yes-or-no questions and solve simple math problems. Electrodes measuring body and brain activity verified that the participants were not awake. Martin Dresler, a sleep researcher at the Donders Institute, who ran the Dutch experiments, said that they were able to verbally deliver new information to the sleeping mind—and to receive responses. Some people could remember the questions they had been asked when they woke up. “This is a form of very complex learning,” he told me.

https://xkcd.com/269/

reply
jboggan
1 hour ago
[-]
My wife used to think that I had terrible sleep apnea because I'd repeatedly quit breathing for a minute or two at a time and then gasp for air, but it turned out I was just dreaming about freediving for lobsters.
reply
lazyasciiart
34 minutes ago
[-]
Uh, do you freedive while awake?
reply
squibonpig
1 hour ago
[-]
It's gonna be really sad in 10-15 years when all the sc bros are hustling and grindsetting their dreams away.
reply
notahacker
1 hour ago
[-]
Can't wait for the LinkedIn posts about their day to start even earlier than the 4am workout and 5am meditation with strategic dreaming between 1am and 3am.

Type LUCID in the comments for a how to guide...

reply
Argonaut998
49 minutes ago
[-]
reply
magiclaw
1 hour ago
[-]
Now that's dystopian!
reply
fizzbar
1 hour ago
[-]
Top performers manufacture 33% more hours in the day thanks to this one weird trick!
reply
zombot
59 minutes ago
[-]
Now there is no excuse anymore to be working less than 24 hours a day.
reply
tkfoss
2 hours ago
[-]
tl:dr "Andrillon warned against trying to harness the sleeping mind in the service of the waking world." https://www.nature.com/articles/s41539-024-00276-0
reply
econ
1 hour ago
[-]
Proper sleep definitely isn't optional.
reply
metalman
2 hours ago
[-]
There is no such thing as "should". The thing is possible, therefore humans will do it. The only question is, who is we?
reply
azan_
2 hours ago
[-]
Well, you shouldn't smoke yet people do it. I think the article posits question whether we should in similar spirit.
reply
econ
2 hours ago
[-]
After two weeks I woke up and didn't notice it was German tv. Eventually after 5 minutes an unknown word came along. I still can't speak it.

When 13 i use to code till 1-2 am. In school I slept with my eyes open till 11. The information was stored and organized but I was unaware of it. I remember tests where all of the questions talked about topics I never spend a conscious thought on. But I knew all the answers. Quite the surreal experience.

Teachers sometimes wondered if I was still in the room or they just asked questions. My mind would grep the most recent chunk of speech, parse it and respond as if nothing unusual was going on. The mind raced but I talked slowly to portray the slight delay more natural.

I learned you don't want other people's bullshit in your head. It needs to be questioned first.

reply