Six Years Perfecting Maps on WatchOS
252 points
9 hours ago
| 13 comments
| david-smith.org
| HN
thrownawaysz
8 hours ago
[-]
The fact that there is no 1st party Apple made hiking and topography map on the Apple Watch is such a failure, not even on the most expensive “made for explorers” Watch Ultra. And things like gpx import is just a mere dream

It’s a lifestyle device after all but still

reply
kumarvvr
3 hours ago
[-]
> there is no 1st party Apple made hiking and topography map on the Apple Watch is such a failure

I remember a time when Apple was chided for integrating functionalities of popular apps into its OS.

Apple created an incredibly awesome device, and its up to the market to make full use of its potential. Why would it be a failure for Apple to not make such an app?

reply
interstice
3 hours ago
[-]
Because they don't allow deeper integrations maybe? I still don't have a watch face layout I like.
reply
interstice
3 hours ago
[-]
Oh and while I'm here the single layer non editable menu / weird grid is also the worst. I grew up texting under the desk on a nine key and only checking after I'd selected the contact to send to. Give me that level of muscle memory again someone, anyone, please.
reply
porsager
7 minutes ago
[-]
I made Type Nine for iPhone, and have waited a long time for Apple to open up for doing it on the watch.

https://typenineapp.com

PS. I typed this under my desk!

reply
modeless
3 hours ago
[-]
Pebble watches are operated with physical buttons and you can definitely take advantage of muscle memory.
reply
rjzzleep
2 hours ago
[-]
That is quite literally how every part of Cocoa was polished. Things such as sidebars, notifications, came from third party libraries, Growl, etc. were all design patterns from the community. Isn't that also how iTunes came to be? Apple trying to acquire the best music players to integrate into its ecosystem? It's somewhat sad to observe what become of apple.
reply
caycep
2 hours ago
[-]
maybe the culture should be for them to contract with popular app makers to be "The" default app for x amount of years or such, vs sherlocking.
reply
refulgentis
2 hours ago
[-]
That’s a somewhat obvious flattening of perspective. While it’s clever we can make both positions sound silly, it illuminates nothing while throwing shade.
reply
Centigonal
5 hours ago
[-]
I trust people like David Smith and companies like onX more than Apple when it comes to creating and supporting a top tier outdoor mapping app.
reply
dylan604
1 hour ago
[-]
Maybe some people are too young to remember Apple's Maps v1. Even Tim Apple recently mentioned that debacle in what was essentially an exit interview.
reply
SllX
1 hour ago
[-]
I recently switched back to Google Maps after Apple announced ads were coming to Apple Maps, since if the default Maps app is going to be saddled with ads on my thousands of dollars worth of Apple hardware anyway, I may as well use the best. And yeah, let’s be honest, Apple Maps is good enough for most use cases, but Google Maps blows it out of the fucking water.

In that light, I may be hard pressed to call it a debacle, but it’s still third-rate.

reply
jsbisviewtiful
4 hours ago
[-]
Apple is so intent on making the Apple Watch a catch-all that it doesn’t necessarily do any specific activity amazingly. After three Apple Watches over many years I finally sold my 10 last year and won’t be buying another. I bought a Coros and am pretty pleased with it, would consider a Garmin in the future. Coros and Garmin devices are built with activity in mind and not unneeded apps, like Uber. Garmin and Coros both have maps too.
reply
throwaway27448
1 hour ago
[-]
Tbf there is no such app for the iphone either
reply
cromka
7 hours ago
[-]
Honestly, the less Apple made apps, the better for the ecosystem and the quality of the apps in general. Apple's recent "sherlocked" apps are not good quality at all, but they make it substantially more difficult for 3rd parties to compete with the now default offerings.
reply
Sir_Twist
6 hours ago
[-]
Not a developer, but I feel like Apple improving the defaults has been good for the ecosystem. The Reminders app is an example of this, because as it has gotten better over the years, the baseline for a good iOS to-do app has been raised, without reducing the market.
reply
Schiendelman
6 hours ago
[-]
I agree 100%. I ended up building myself a utility to wrangle my reminders (like keep them from getting missed/lost) instead of using a third-party app.
reply
coldtea
5 hours ago
[-]
Can you describe that utility?
reply
Schiendelman
3 hours ago
[-]
Yeah! I mean I published it on the app store, too. It does three core things: 1) Makes sure every reminder gets a date and time if it doesn't have one 2) Snowplows them ahead of you, so if you go on vacation they're still in the near future 3) Moves reminders out of the way if you accept or create a calendar event conflicting with it

It also preserves ordering when moving things (hence my snowplow approach).

Soon it'll summarize what you did that day so you can feel good about what you get done - that's coming shortly, I'm testing the feature for another few days.

There are a bunch of settings to tweak this - picking what reminder lists to include, setting a time window for when it'll reschedule things, etc.

This should link to it:

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/reminder-wrangler/id6759400510

reply
xp84
5 hours ago
[-]
Nice try, Claude Code
reply
coldtea
4 hours ago
[-]
Is that meant to be a joke? I've been on HN for over a decade. Closer to ELIZA's era than that of LLMs.

I'm curious because I'm also interested in hacking the Reminders app via its API, to add some features in a side app

reply
Schiendelman
3 hours ago
[-]
If you try it out, I'm curious what you'd add! I'd be happy to make improvements.
reply
SllX
6 hours ago
[-]
Generally speaking, Apple should be improving and adding to the base operating system all the time, including new apps. It is better for their users including new users if the phone itself is capable of more out of the box.

Where they fall short though, the App Store is right there. There’s almost always a better alternative for those who value having something better.

reply
ileonichwiesz
44 minutes ago
[-]
> There’s almost always a better alternative for those who value having something better.

That alternative comes with a $60/year subscription these days, though.

reply
coldtea
5 hours ago
[-]
Is it? They have a platform you can run other apps on, and this one in TFA and others provides this functionality.
reply
joe_mamba
6 hours ago
[-]
Didn't it take them 10+ years to make a calculator app for the iPad?
reply
necovek
33 minutes ago
[-]
What I find curious is that the entire article seems to be framed in responding to the needs of a single user of the app — the author themselves.

Yet the app is published and has a great App Store review score of 4.8 with 170k+ reviews, and same score with 35k+ reviews for the Watch.

How does the author get feedback and respond to other customers? Or is this simply scratching one's own itch demonstrating its usefulness for others once again?

reply
som
7 hours ago
[-]
Great evolution story. Also love seeing what can be achieved by stepping outside design lines, re. centred, symmetrical UIs. Makes me want an apple watch ;)

As an aside there's a screenshot in the article showing the Hidden Valley at Glen Coe, which happens to be one of my favourite short walks in Scotland.

A less happy aside of that aside is the house at the base of the valley. I used to look at it dreamily as we drove past, always closed up, nestled by itself in a remote nook between the mountains. What an extraordinary place it would be to live. The park for the hike was only a couple of hundred metres up the road. A few years later I recognised the house in a Louis Theroux doco, when he travelled there with its owner - TV personality Jimmy Saville. Wow. And then a few years later again, after I'd returned to Australia, it came out, posthumous, that Saville was one of the UK's most prolific child and sexual predators. Horrific stuff. The name and outline of the cottage structure can actually be seen at the top of the map in the screenshot.

reply
apt-apt-apt-apt
8 hours ago
[-]
For others curious like I was, it seems he hired a cartographer to render essentially a set of huge, nice-looking, custom map images with details like hiking trails that Apple Maps doesn't have.

So unlike Apple Maps, which is dynamically rendered, it basically shows image tiles. It allows for a nicer-looking, more detailed map, but affects things like needing separate downloads for different zoom levels, rotation, updatability.

reply
n8cpdx
6 hours ago
[-]
The use of the cartographer to generate separate designs and the technology used to render/deliver those designs are two entirely separate concerns.

His original map provider offers both vector and raster tile services: https://www.thunderforest.com/maps/outdoors/

A common pattern is to use a vector tile service + style definition directly or to generate raster tiles if those are desired.

reply
apt-apt-apt-apt
6 hours ago
[-]
Good point, I assumed he was using images because his screenshots show text perfectly following the curves of rivers, which seems hard to do with dynamic rendering.
reply
dzogchen
8 hours ago
[-]
I think this may not even be possible because Apple does not give access to the Metal graphics API on Apple Watch to third-party developers.
reply
SpyCoder77
8 hours ago
[-]
As a pedometer++ user, it is amazing the attention to detail David has maintained over the years. The evolution is crazy.
reply
Amorymeltzer
8 hours ago
[-]
He really is such a committed and dedicated developer. This here is of course a perfect example—"So… I commissioned a custom map" aka hiring a cartographer—but it was really cool how he blew up with Widgetsmith because he put in the effort with Watchsmith before, and was basically the world's expert on widgets? Couldn't happen to a better guy.
reply
monk_grilla
6 hours ago
[-]
I’m interested since it’s clear this is a passionate and talented developer, but it seems the primary feature is step tracking, which iPhone already does by default. Is Pedometer++’s step counting somehow more accurate?
reply
SpyCoder77
6 hours ago
[-]
Yes, the primary feature that is being marketed is step tracking, but the app in general is much more than that. It's like how flighty just is a wrapper for the flights API that you could access through Google, yet flighty is the best app for flight tracking nonetheless and is a really cool app.
reply
bcraven
2 hours ago
[-]
I appreciate this comes from an outside perspective as I've not heard of this before, but "Pedometer++ 8" sounds like "Dissertation_final_final_v8.docx" to me.
reply
AbuAssar
1 hour ago
[-]
It is just Pedometer++

The 8 is the version number that launched yesterday with this feature

reply
kobieps
4 hours ago
[-]
I spend a lot of time in wilderness areas that I don't know, and I simply pull my phone out of my pocket to see where I am. My watch measures my heart rate and that's it. While I have no doubt that pedometer++ is great and the work that went into it is impressive, I can't really see myself switching away from a big screen workflow to see exactly where I am. And I don't need to check where I am every 5 minutes. Typically only every 30 minutes or longer. Dunno, maybe I'm missing something :shrug:
reply
kweiza
7 hours ago
[-]
Static tiles on a watch is the right call. Tried dynamic rendering on a constrained device once and pan/zoom got eaten by GC pauses every frame.
reply
timojaask
7 hours ago
[-]
There’s no GC on watchOS, it uses ARC
reply
arjie
8 hours ago
[-]
Apple Maps on WatchOS is pretty good but the usual routine is that I get on my bike with a route set and 3 minutes in the “are you working out?” screen takes over and I can’t see the maps without stopping to turn it off. Surely that screen should turn into a notification or silently record after some time without taking over the screen.

I’m surprised to hear people at Apple work on this because surely they must encounter this issue.

If this guys maps can somehow take the screen and hold it, I think he’s got a killer feature for me. Though I glanced at the App Store page and it wasn’t clear to me which features are subscription gated and which ones aren’t and I despise apps that won’t tell me till I’ve set everything up (it just feels so frustrating that it wasn’t clear ahead of time) so I’ll probably just endure and try to remember to start a workout manually so it won’t take over.

reply
Dork_Sider
7 hours ago
[-]
You can also turn off the "are you working out" feature. It's in the settings of the workout part. Just turn off "Check In Reminders"
reply
maz1b
6 hours ago
[-]
Really enjoyed reading this. A lot. Reminds me when I was a teenager reading technical blogs in the earlier days of the internet.

BTW, that last line about hiring/commissioning a cartographer, very rad and cool :~)

reply
Razengan
3 hours ago
[-]
While traveling in another country, I once forgot my iPhone passcode (don't ask, I'm autistic like that)

After a few retries it put me on a 2 hour timeout.

I had to get back to my room. I knew the way back on foot well enough, about 30 minutes away, but I wanted to take a look at the map anyway.

I thought I'd try it on my Apple Watch Ultra 3. It was a few months ago so it was the latest OS.

There were a few bugs in trying to do that simple task, like when typing out the name of a location the keyboard kept disappearing as if the UI was crashing or something.

I sighed, muttered a few curses at the state of things and the people in charge who let it get this way, and lowered my wrist and just enjoyed the stroll.

Like so many things in Apple software since the past 5 or so years, so much shit just doesn't work when you REALLY need it. F'n hell

reply
opentokix
30 minutes ago
[-]
And it's a f:ing subscription delete
reply
davidkuennen
14 minutes ago
[-]
How do you expect the developers to pay for the service? Map tiles alone are already very expensive and data heavy.
reply
mrcwinn
2 hours ago
[-]
Awesome work, truly. (But I'll stick with my Garmin.)
reply