Do women’s mate preferences change across the ovulatory cycle? (2014) [pdf]
36 points
by rzk
2 hours ago
| 9 comments
| martiehaselton.com
| HN
brodo
22 minutes ago
[-]
The whole field of evolutionary psychology is in a replication crisis, and there are several newer studies that did not find any evidence for any changes in 'mate preference' across the ovulatory cycle.

General sexual desire, but not desire for uncommitted sexual relationships, tracks changes in women's hormonal status https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29287282/

Meta-Analysis of Menstrual Cycle Effects on Women’s Mate Preferences https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/175407391452307...

reply
zug_zug
1 hour ago
[-]
This research is one of the important studies in my own understanding of the world. I think it's the type of thing people are cautious to talk about too much because it might drive a certain type of person crazy and lead them to overcompensate in weird/destructive ways.

I also remember there's a study on how hormonal birth control (which causes the body to perceive itself as pregnant) affects these preferences too. In some ways we really are "experimenting on production." I also think there's some hesitation to talk about that a lot and come-across as anti-choice.

But beliefs must come from the research, not vice-versa.

reply
arowthway
35 minutes ago
[-]
I love evolutionary psychology trivia but for me it's kind of hard to meaningfully fit 0.13 standard deviation shift in preferences into my world model.
reply
wjnc
1 minute ago
[-]
I stubbed my toe. I don’t feel like ice cream today.
reply
K0balt
39 minutes ago
[-]
In the end we’re just improvements on the worm/tube plan, and we run things based on chemical soup that is mostly inside our bodies these days, but whose composition has a significant influence on our behavior. Thats why it’s great to have a neocortex, so we con at least be marginally in control of our decisions if we maintain a consistent effort to do so.

But yeah, in my empirical experience, moon phases, ovolatory cycles, hormone manipulation therapies… all have a gigantic impact on our base physiological and psychological state. I live in a place where the insects operate on a lunar phase, and the plants proactively change their operations in that rhythm to match. You can taste and see the difference in tree sap here based on the lunar phase, it becomes thicker, darker, and more bitter days in advance of the insect hatching.

Why would we think we are somehow a special exception from the web of life that created us?

reply
block_dagger
1 hour ago
[-]
Findings of TFA: Yes.

Women show a robust increase in attraction to cues of ancestral genetic quality (body masculinity, behavioral dominance) on high-fertility days, but only when evaluating men as short-term/unspecified sexual partners, not long-term partners.

reply
andyferris
58 minutes ago
[-]
Can we summarize this as "people get horny sometimes" and "ovulating people get horny"? Or is that too reductive?
reply
acters
33 minutes ago
[-]
I am guessing they are trying to make a distinction from mental horny vs physical horny
reply
usrnm
46 minutes ago
[-]
Which only supports my belief that with the proliferation of contraception tying sex and long-term partnership together is becoming a useless anachronism
reply
hambes
53 minutes ago
[-]
I am not scientist enough to judge this, so please someone enlighten me: most categories i've read through that find a shift do so with an increase of about 0.1-0.2 standard deviations. that does not sound significant to me. is that enough to make the claims this study makes?
reply
Palomides
23 minutes ago
[-]
considering this is a review aggregating a bunch of small n studies from before we acknowledged the replication crisis in psychology, I'm going with "no"
reply
leoncos
1 hour ago
[-]
Many behaviors are determined by hormones. Men are no exception. When calm, men tend to prefer intellectual women, but when they're impulsive after drinking in a bar, they prefer sexy women.
reply
dnnddidiej
1 hour ago
[-]
It is OK! Don't forget we are animals first. Obviously we need that neocortex to keep decisions in check!
reply
iberator
1 hour ago
[-]
Women with higher testosterone levels prefer more risks.

For example: when women are starting dating and fell in love: their testosterone level go up for 2 months

reply
rusk
1 hour ago
[-]
In my experience it’s usually the other way around
reply
crims0n
8 minutes ago
[-]
It is a curious thing how drinking affects people in different ways. Some people get reflective, others belligerent.
reply
Scroll_Swe
41 minutes ago
[-]
>determined by hormones

>but when they're impulsive after drinking in a bar

Is alcohol hormones?

What is an "intellectual women"?

What is a "sexy women"?

Also, where are you from? Getting a very thirdy worldy "ESL" vibe from your post. Europe? USA? Canada? Australia? No?

I can assure you, where I am in Sweden, there are plenty of women who are intellectual and sexy.

Also, I have never ever in my life been attracted to some kind of bimbo "sexy" woman as often stereotyped. Especially the Kim Kardashian type, I feel it is a very african american style of woman.

Just like how some women like skinny men and some like burly ones.

reply
mike_hock
1 hour ago
[-]
Do women keep changing their settings in that Gnome 2 fork over the course of their ovulatory cycle?

Oh, that kind of mate.

reply
bombcar
1 hour ago
[-]
I was hoping for chess moves, myself.
reply
warumdarum
1 hour ago
[-]
The ovulatory cycle where a peasant becomes a queen.
reply
Nzen
1 hour ago
[-]
I don't know what an ovulatory cycle feels like; but, I trust Lindsay Doe's account [0] of how she feels across a given period.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLXxxHVOeec 11 minutes

reply
Jensson
55 minutes ago
[-]
It probably feels a bit like before and after ejaculation for a man, just it happens way quicker for men. Pretty sure if you studied that you'd find mens preferences in women changes a lot as well.
reply
Hnrobert42
1 hour ago
[-]
It's 2026, and I still can't read a PDF on mobile.

I must be doing something wrong. I'm using FF Focus. Is that it? I tried Safari. Either they moved the reader button, or it's not present for PDFs. Help me Obi-Wan.

reply
crims0n
6 minutes ago
[-]
PDFs are generally meant for printed paper, it's not you - it's the medium.
reply
bestouff
1 hour ago
[-]
Under Firefox Focus I can read it if I manually zoom and scroll. Not ideal.
reply
sameersri2004
2 hours ago
[-]
Yes, it does from follicular to ovulation...
reply