Alternatives to Nested If Function
12 points
4 days ago
| 3 comments
| medium.com
| HN
▲
pavel_lishin
1 hour ago
[-]
There was an excellent excel video by ... someone famous in our field whose name escapes me, and one thing I internalized from that was that VLOOKUP is always a bad choice, and INDEX + MATCH is almost always what you want instead.

About once a year I go looking for that video, and about half the time, I find it, and half the time I don't. I should really bookmark it.

reply
▲
imurray
1 hour ago
[-]
I think you're thinking of "You Suck at Excel" by Joel Spolsky. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JxBg4sMusIg

Lots of past HN discussion... https://hn.algolia.com/?q=you+suck+at+excel

That video was before the introduction of xlookup, which I believe is now worth considering over index and match.

reply
▲
pavel_lishin
1 hour ago
[-]
Yes! Thank you!
reply
▲
abstractspoon
4 days ago
[-]
In Excel
reply
▲
jonasenordin
1 hour ago
[-]
Important_Distinction. _That_Should_Be_in_the_Headline_Maybe.

Thanks, saving a click, not going for the article; not that it's necessarily bad or uninteresting; not that I wouldn't if I had more time on this planet.

reply
▲
jonasenordin
45 minutes ago
[-]
Went ahead and clicked anyway, scientifically-minded that I am. No appreciable disillusionment occurred.

Didn't Excel gain the ability to use names at some point?

Is 'anominal' a word? As in 'anominal' or 'non-nominal' programming, or 'un-' or 'dis-'. Maybe Excel rises to 'pseudonominal'.

--- quote ---

Most users would use below nested IF function

=IF(B2=$F$3,$G$3,IF(B2=$F$4,$G$4,IF(B2=$F$5,$G$5,IF(B2=$F$6,$G$6,IF(B2=$F$7,$G$7,IF(B2=$F$8,$G$8))))))

reply
▲
esafak
1 hour ago
[-]
A benighted programming language if I ever saw one. I don't use Excel so maybe someone call tell me why people don't just migrate their queries to Python: https://support.microsoft.com/en-US/Excel/python/get-started...

Is support poor? Competitors can do it: https://www.quadratichq.com/ (look at their VLOOKUP example)

reply