Ask HN: Why is not using AI considered a form of arrogance?
5 points
1 hour ago
| 8 comments
| HN
You would expect only people who have a very high opinion of themselves to not feel the need to use AI.
retentionissue
1 hour ago
[-]
I rarely use AI and avoid at all costs unless forced to use it by my job.

Every time I do use it, it's usually incorrect and just adds time to the task. I nearly always end up having to refer to a physical book or previously written notes to get the answer I need.

I have no ill will towards anybody who does use it nor do I care who uses it – It's their choice if they would rather defer to a machine to make simple decisions.

reply
mikewarot
14 minutes ago
[-]
Trying out AI is a fun and sometimes useful thing to do.

But you should never trust it completely. A lot of people have already died because they trusted it with their lives. "Full self driving" isn't.

reply
dare944
32 minutes ago
[-]
> You would expect only people who have a very high opinion of themselves to not feel the need to use AI.

Please explain why my 82 year-old mother-in-law needs to use AI. Is it just so you won't consider her arrogant?

reply
amichail
19 minutes ago
[-]
She lived long enough to see this miracle come to fruition and yet she doesn't want to check it out?
reply
anenefan
1 hour ago
[-]
I don't code as such any more, but the obvious two reasons I see is that coders would avoid it is for copyright issues as well as, since one doesn't know what the llm was trained on, for not unwittingly [1] introducing a crafty not yet known to the public exploit.

[1] Assuming that if LLMs were that good, all code would presently be double checked and exploits and back doors will shortly coming to an end - unless the reason it hasn't is a marketing issue.

reply
sscaryterry
1 hour ago
[-]
We all have to do what we have to do. I don't consider the fact that people refuse to use AI necessarily arrogant, they merely have the choice at this stage.

There are some who exhibit arrogance/aggression and like to virtue signalling to us other mere mortals, which is annoying.

Nonetheless, I preferred life before LLMs. Now I'm making the best of a bad situation, and going with the flow. Too old to fight a losing battle.

reply
theandrewbailey
1 hour ago
[-]
What if someone has evaluated the pros and cons, maybe even tried using AI, and decided it's not worth it?
reply
jsabess24
1 hour ago
[-]
I don’t consider it arrogant but people are free to choose what they utilize
reply
amichail
1 hour ago
[-]
Not on Hacker News though.
reply
minimaxir
1 hour ago
[-]
It's less often arrogance and more often ideological. Some programmers, especially those in creative industries, feel the negative externalities of AI don't justify its use.

However, some programmers believe that "AI can't program" with their last time using an LLM was years ago, which is more ignorant of current trends than arrogant.

reply